A Statistical Method to Predict Flow Permanence in Dryland Streams from Time Series of Stream Temperature

• Published in: Water (Basel) Vol. 9; no. 12; p. 946
• Main Authors: Arismendi, Ivan, Dunham, Jason, Heck, Michael, Schultz, Luke, Hockman-Wert, David
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Basel MDPI AG 01.12.2017
• Subjects: Air temperature; Channels; Climate; Deserts; Drying; Ecosystems; Environmental changes; Ephemeral streams; Flow; flow permanence; Freshwater ecosystems; Hidden Markov Models; Information processing; Instrumentation; Markov chains; Markov processes; Resistors; River networks; Rivers; Signal detection; Statistical analysis; stream drying; stream networks; Streams; Temperature effects; Terrestrial environments; Time series
• ISSN: 2073-4441; 2073-4441
• DOI: 10.3390/w9120946

Intermittent and ephemeral streams represent more than half of the length of the global river network. Dryland freshwater ecosystems are especially vulnerable to changes in human-related water uses as well as shifts in terrestrial climates. Yet, the description and quantification of patterns of flow permanence in these systems is challenging mostly due to difficulties in instrumentation. Here, we took advantage of existing stream temperature datasets in dryland streams in the northwest Great Basin desert, USA, to extract critical information on climate-sensitive patterns of flow permanence. We used a signal detection technique, Hidden Markov Models (HMMs), to extract information from daily time series of stream temperature to diagnose patterns of stream drying. Specifically, we applied HMMs to time series of daily standard deviation (SD) of stream temperature (i.e., dry stream channels typically display highly variable daily temperature records compared to wet stream channels) between April and August (2015–2016). We used information from paired stream and air temperature data loggers as well as co-located stream temperature data loggers with electrical resistors as confirmatory sources of the timing of stream drying. We expanded our approach to an entire stream network to illustrate the utility of the method to detect patterns of flow permanence over a broader spatial extent. We successfully identified and separated signals characteristic of wet and dry stream conditions and their shifts over time. Most of our study sites within the entire stream network exhibited a single state over the entire season (80%), but a portion of them showed one or more shifts among states (17%). We provide recommendations to use this approach based on a series of simple steps. Our findings illustrate a successful method that can be used to rigorously quantify flow permanence regimes in streams using existing records of stream temperature.