How conceptualizing obesity as a disease affects beliefs about weight, and associated weight stigma and clinical decision‐making in health care

• Published in: British journal of health psychology Vol. 28; no. 2; pp. 291 - 305
• Main Authors: Rathbone, Joanne A., Cruwys, Tegan, Jetten, Jolanda, Banas, Kasia, Smyth, Lillian, Murray, Kristen
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: England Wiley Subscription Services, Inc 01.05.2023
• Subjects: Beliefs; Clinical Decision-Making; Clinical outcomes; Concept formation; Delivery of Health Care; Discrimination; Endorsements; health care; health professionals; Health Promotion; Heuristic; Humans; Manipulation; Medical personnel; Migraine; Migraine Disorders - therapy; Obesity; Obesity - therapy; obesity as a disease; Stereotypes; Stigma; Treatment needs; Weight Prejudice; weight stigma; weight‐based discrimination; health professionals; weight stigma; weight-based discrimination; health care; obesity as a disease
• ISSN: 1359-107X; 2044-8287
• DOI: 10.1111/bjhp.12625

Objectives This study empirically investigated how conceptualizing obesity as a disease (i.e., pathologizing obesity) affects beliefs about weight, and weight stigma and discrimination among health professionals. Design An experiment that manipulated the pathologization of obesity was completed by a multi‐nation sample of health professionals from Australia, UK, and USA (N = 365). Methods Participants were randomly assigned to one of two conditions where they were asked to conceptualize obesity as a disease or not a disease; then presented with a hypothetical medical profile of a patient with obesity who was seeking care for migraines. We measured biogenetic causal beliefs about obesity, endorsement of weight as a heuristic for health, negative obesity stereotypes, and treatment decisions. Results Participants in the disease (vs. non‐disease) condition endorsed biogenetic causal beliefs more strongly and made more migraine‐related treatment recommendations. No effect of the manipulation was found for the remaining outcomes. Biogenetic causal beliefs about obesity were associated with less weight stigma. Endorsing weight as a heuristic for health was associated with greater weight stigma and differential treatment recommendations focused more on the patient's weight and less on their migraines. Conclusions Pathologizing obesity may reinforce biogenetic explanations for obesity. Evidence demonstrates complex associations between weight‐related beliefs and weight stigma and discrimination. Biogenetic causal beliefs were associated with less weight stigma, while endorsing weight as a heuristic for health was associated with greater weight stigma and differential treatment. Further research is needed to inform policies that can promote health without perpetuating weight‐based rejection in health care.