A comparison of obstetric and nonobstetric anesthesia malpractice claims

• Published in: Anesthesiology (Philadelphia) Vol. 74; no. 2; pp. 242 - 249
• Main Authors: CHADWICK, H. S, POSNER, K, CAPLAN, R. A, WARD, R. J, CHENEY, F. W
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Hagerstown, MD Lippincott 01.02.1991
• Subjects: Adult; Anesthesia; Anesthesia Department, Hospital - legislation & jurisprudence; Anesthesia, Conduction - adverse effects; Anesthesia, General - adverse effects; Anesthesia, Obstetrical - adverse effects; Anesthesia. Intensive care medicine. Transfusions. Cell therapy and gene therapy; Biological and medical sciences; Data Collection; Female; Humans; Insurance, Liability - statistics & numerical data; Local anesthesia. Pain (treatment); Malpractice - economics; Malpractice - statistics & numerical data; Medical sciences; Middle Aged; Pregnancy; United States; United States; Human; Surgery; Malpractice; Database; Anesthesia; Delivery; Statistical study; Obstetrics; Comparative study
• ISSN: 0003-3022; 1528-1175
• DOI: 10.1097/00000542-199102000-00009

Malpractice claims filed against anesthesiologists for care involving obstetric (OB) anesthesia (n = 190) were taken from the American Society of Anesthesiologists' Closed Claims Database and compared to claims not involving OB cases (n = 1351). The most common complications in the OB claims were (percentage of all OB claims): maternal death (22%), newborn brain damage (20%), and headache (12%). In contrast, the most common complications in the nonobstetric (non-OB) group were (percentage of all non-OB claims): death (39%), nerve damage (16%), and brain damage (13%). The group of OB claims contained a proportionately greater number of minor injuries, such as headache, backache, pain during anesthesia, and emotional injury (32%) compared to the non-OB claims (4%). Complications due to aspiration and convulsions were more common among the OB cases. The standard of care was judged to have been met in 46% of OB and 39% of non-OB claims. This difference is not statistically significant. Claims involving general anesthesia were more frequently associated with severe injuries and resulted in higher payments than did claims involving regional anesthesia. Payments were made in a similar proportion of OB and non-OB claims (53 and 59%, respectively). For cases in which payments were made, the median payment for OB claims was significantly greater ($203,000) than for non-OB claims ($85,000; P less than or equal to 0.05).