Formalizing community forest tenure rights: A theory of change and conditions for success

• Published in: Forest policy and economics Vol. 141; p. 102766
• Main Authors: Kusters, Koen, de Graaf, Maartje, Ascarrunz, Nataly, Benneker, Charlotte, Boot, René, van Kanten, Rudi, Livingstone, John, Maindo, Alphonse, Mendoza, Heidi, Purwanto, Edi, Rodríguez, Carlos, Ssemmanda, Richard, Thang, Tran Nam, Zagt, Roderick
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Elsevier B.V 01.08.2022
• Subjects: community forestry; Community forests; Customary rights; forest management; Forest policy; forests; governance; Indigenous peoples and local communities; livelihood; natural resources conservation; sustainable communities; Tenure; Tenure; Indigenous peoples and local communities; Forest policy; Community forests; Customary rights
• ISSN: 1389-9341; 1872-7050
• DOI: 10.1016/j.forpol.2022.102766

The formalization of community forest tenure rights is expected to promote sustainable community forest management, and is seen as a way to combine objectives related to environmental conservation, livelihood improvement, and local self-determination. However, the formalization of forest tenure rights by itself, does not automatically result in the intended impacts. There is a need to better understand the conditions under which communities are able to use these rights to achieve positive outcomes across multiple dimensions. We formulated a simple theory of change that underlies the formalization of community forest tenure rights, and used it to assess the outcomes, bottlenecks and enabling conditions of community forest tenure models across the forested tropics. Based on this analysis, we identified ten conditions that need to be in place for community forest tenure rights formalization to achieve the intended impacts. The theory of change and associated conditions form a generic conceptual framework that can be used to inform policy and practice of actors supporting community forest tenure rights, including civil society organizations and government agencies. •Community forest tenure can contribute to conservation, livelihoods and justice.•We propose a learning and monitoring framework for related policy and practice.•The framework highlights potential impact pathways and conditions for success.