Performance on the Nephrology In-Training Examination and ABIM Nephrology Certification Examination Outcomes

• Published in: Clinical journal of the American Society of Nephrology Vol. 13; no. 5; pp. 710 - 717
• Main Authors: Jurich, Daniel, Duhigg, Lauren M, Plumb, Troy J, Haist, Steven A, Hawley, Janine L, Lipner, Rebecca S, Smith, Laurel, Norby, Suzanne M
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States American Society of Nephrology 07.05.2018
• Subjects: Original; Fellowships and Scholarships; nephrology; Regression Analysis; Confidence Intervals; Feedback; Board Certification Examination; Fellowship Programs; In-Training Examination; American Board of Internal Medicine; Schools, Medical; Certification; Cohort Studies
• ISSN: 1555-9041; 1555-905X
• DOI: 10.2215/CJN.05580517

Medical specialty and subspecialty fellowship programs administer subject-specific in-training examinations to provide feedback about level of medical knowledge to fellows preparing for subsequent board certification. This study evaluated the association between the American Society of Nephrology In-Training Examination and the American Board of Internal Medicine Nephrology Certification Examination in terms of scores and passing status. The study included 1684 nephrology fellows who completed the American Society of Nephrology In-Training Examination in their second year of fellowship training between 2009 and 2014. Regression analysis examined the association between In-Training Examination and first-time Nephrology Certification Examination scores as well as passing status relative to other standardized assessments. This cohort included primarily men (62%) and international medical school graduates (62%), and fellows had an average age of 32 years old at the time of first completing the Nephrology Certification Examination. An overwhelming majority (89%) passed the Nephrology Certification on their first attempt. In-Training Examination scores showed the strongest association with first-time Nephrology Certification Examination scores, accounting for approximately 50% of the total explained variance in the model. Each SD increase in In-Training Examination scores was associated with a difference of 30 U (95% confidence interval, 27 to 33) in certification performance. In-Training Examination scores also were significantly associated with passing status on the Nephrology Certification Examination on the first attempt (odds ratio, 3.46 per SD difference in the In-Training Examination; 95% confidence interval, 2.68 to 4.54). An In-Training Examination threshold of 375, approximately 1 SD below the mean, yielded a positive predictive value of 0.92 and a negative predictive value of 0.50. American Society of Nephrology In-Training Examination performance is significantly associated with American Board of Internal Medicine Nephrology Certification Examination score and passing status.