A case study of the legitimation process undertaken to gain support for an information system in a Chinese university

• Published in: European journal of information systems Vol. 21; no. 3; pp. 212 - 228
• Main Authors: Flynn, Donal, Du, Yongqin
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: London Taylor & Francis 01.05.2012; Palgrave Macmillan UK; Taylor & Francis Ltd
• Subjects: adoption; Business and Management; Business Information Systems; Case studies; Colleges & universities; Dependency theory; Information systems; Information Systems and Communication Service; information systems development; Innovation/Technology Management; interpretivist qualitative case study; Legitimacy; legitimation; Operations Research/Decision Theory; Organizational change; Perceptions; Research Article; stakeholder acceptance; stakeholder support; Stakeholders; Studies; Success factors; Technology Acceptance Model; Technology adoption; University students; China; adoption; stakeholder support; stakeholder acceptance; legitimacy; legitimation; information systems development; interpretivist qualitative case study
• ISSN: 0960-085X; 1476-9344
• DOI: 10.1057/ejis.2011.27

This research examines the legitimation process that was undertaken to gain stakeholder support for the development of a smartcard system for student services at a local university in China. We employed a theoretical framework consisting of Suchman's typology of legitimacy and the Legitimation Activity Model (LAM) for sense-making of the process. We obtained insights into how legitimation of the system was gained, maintained and repaired through the project team's strategic actions. We conceptualized the rotation of legitimation gaining, maintaining and repairing activities in the project and make suggestions for improving the LAM. We emphasize that monitoring and evaluating legitimation is a dynamic, continuous process, involving the concept of legitimation status, and linking the planned actions of legitimation- gaining and responsive actions for legitimation maintaining and repairing. We suggest that to achieve legitimation for information systems, managers should plan strategies to construct and present an appropriate image of the system, in which stakeholders perceive that it meets their needs, and, in addition, closely monitor the status of legitimation granted over a continuous period. This is because legitimation is a 'fragile flower' that may wilt if not attended to adequately.