Integrating Constructivist Grounded Theory with a Patient-Oriented Research Approach to Enhance Health Promotion Research

• Published in: International journal of qualitative methods Vol. 22
• Main Authors: Nelson, Heather J., Bally, Jill M. G., Spurr, Shelley, Foulds, Heather, de Padua, Anthony
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Los Angeles, CA SAGE Publications 01.11.2023; Sage Publications Ltd; SAGE Publishing
• Subjects: End users; Flexibility; Grounded theory; Health behavior; Health education; Health promotion; Health research; Intention; Intentionality; Money; Patients; Research methodology; Researchers; Rigour; Stakeholders; Teams; constructivist grounded theory; patient-oriented research; qualitative research; health promotion research
• ISSN: 1609-4069; 1609-4069
• DOI: 10.1177/16094069231218657

Aim To critically explore the value and challenges of combining a traditional methodology (constructivist grounded theory) with a newer approach (Patient-Oriented Research) in nursing research. Overview of the Issue Researchers need to examine novel approaches to research which incorporate the thoughts and ideas of patients and stakeholders in order to ensure that the research is important to end users. However, it is essential to maintain the rigour of traditional methodologies. Therefore, there is a need to explore combining traditional methodologies with new approaches. Results We combined a rigorous methodology with a modern approach to health promotion research that has not been described in the literature. There are numerous synergies between constructivist grounded theory and Patient-Oriented Research. However, tensions exist including pre-conceived knowledge, patients as researchers, and flexibility in research direction. Discussion Constructivist grounded theory with a Patient-Oriented Research approach for use in health promotion research requires thought and intentionality. Consideration of the time and money needed to build relationships and include patient partners as full team members is critical to successful research. Additionally, points of synergy and tension between constructivist grounded theory and Patient-Oriented Research must be navigated with each study. Conclusion Our findings indicate that constructivist grounded theory can be enhanced with a Patient-Oriented Research approach and may lead to increased depth in the development of the substantive grounded theory while also giving voice to the patient-partners. Implications for Profession There is a need for researchers to actively engage patients and stakeholders in a Patient-Oriented Research process while retaining the core of traditional methodologies. Impact This paper will provide researchers with an exemplar to incorporate patients as team members while conducting constructivist grounded theory research.