Life Cycle Assessment of a system for the extraction and transformation of Waste Water Treatment Sludge (WWTS)-derived lipids into biodiesel

• Published in: The Science of the total environment Vol. 883; p. 163637
• Main Authors: Notarnicola, B., Tassielli, G., Renzulli, P.A., Di Capua, R., Astuto, F., Riela, S., Nacci, A., Casiello, M., Testa, M.L., Liotta, L.F., Pastore, C.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Netherlands Elsevier B.V 20.07.2023
• Subjects: Aluminium chloride hexahydrate; Biodiesel production; Life Cycle Assessment; Solid catalysts; Sulfuric acid; Biodiesel production; Solid catalysts; Aluminium chloride hexahydrate; Life Cycle Assessment; Sulfuric acid
• ISSN: 0048-9697; 1879-1026
• DOI: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2023.163637

In recent years, the demand for biofuels has been growing exponentially, as has the interest in biodiesel produced from organic matrices. Particularly interesting, due to its economic and environmental advantages, is the use of the lipids present in sewage sludge as a raw material for the synthesis of biodiesel. The possible processes of this biodiesel synthesis, starting from lipid matter, are represented by the conventional process with sulfuric acid, by the process with aluminium chloride hexahydrate and by processes that use solid catalysts such as those consisting of mixed metal oxides, functionalized halloysites, mesoporous perovskite and functionalized silicas. In literature there are numerous Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) studies concerning biodiesel production systems, but not many studies consider processes that start from sewage sludge and that use solid catalysts. In addition, no LCA studies were reported on solid acid catalysts nor on those based on mixed metal oxides which present some precious advantages, over the homogeneous analogous ones, such as higher recyclability, prevention of foams and corrosion phenomena, and an easier separation and purification of biodiesel product. This research work reports the results of a comparative LCA study applied to a system that uses a solvent free pilot plant for the extraction and transformation of lipids from sewage sludge via seven different scenarios that differ in the type of catalyst used. The biodiesel synthesis scenario using aluminium chloride hexahydrate as catalyst has the best environmental profile. Biodiesel synthesis scenarios using solid catalysts are worse due to higher methanol consumption which requires higher electricity consumption. The worst scenario is the one using functionalized halloysites. Further future developments of the research require the passage from the pilot scale to the industrial scale in order to obtain environmental results to be used for a more reliable comparison with the literature data. [Display omitted] •LCA of seven biodiesel synthesis scenarios starting from WWTS•Comparison of conventional production systems with those using solid catalysts•Electricity consumption and production of solid catalysts are the hot spots of the systems.•The aluminium chloride hexahydrate scenario has the best environmental profile.•The scenario based on ZnO@HNT-TAAI halloysites has the worst environmental profile.