A Computational Multicriteria Optimization Approach to Controller Design for Physical Human-Robot Interaction

• Published in: IEEE transactions on robotics Vol. 36; no. 6; pp. 1791 - 1804
• Main Authors: Aydin, Yusuf, Tokatli, Ozan, Patoglu, Volkan, Basdogan, Cagatay
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: New York IEEE 01.12.2020; The Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc. (IEEE)
• Subjects: Automatic; Computer Science; Control stability; Control systems design; Controllers; Design; Design optimization; Electrical impedance; Engineering Sciences; Fractional order control; Human engineering; Human-Computer Interaction; Human-robot interaction; Integers; interaction controllers; Mathematical analysis; multicriteria optimization; Multiple criterion; Optimization; Parameters; Pareto optimization; physical human-robot interaction (pHRI); Robots; Robustness; Stability criteria; Tradeoffs; transparency-stability robustness tradeoff; Pareto optimization; Multi-criteria optimization; fractional order control; interaction controllers; trade-off between stability robustness and transparency; physical human-robot interaction
• ISSN: 1552-3098; 1941-0468
• DOI: 10.1109/TRO.2020.2998606

Physical human-robot interaction (pHRI) integrates the benefits of human operator and a collaborative robot in tasks involving physical interaction, with the aim of increasing the task performance. However, the design of interaction controllers that achieve safe and transparent operations is challenging, mainly due to the contradicting nature of these objectives. Knowing that attaining perfect transparency is practically unachievable, controllers that allow better compromise between these objectives are desirable. In this article, we propose a multicriteria optimization framework, which jointly optimizes the stability robustness and transparency of a closed-loop pHRI system for a given interaction controller. In particular, we propose a Pareto optimization framework that allows the designer to make informed decisions by thoroughly studying the tradeoff between stability robustness and transparency. The proposed framework involves a search over the discretized controller parameter space to compute the Pareto front curve and a selection of controller parameters that yield maximum attainable transparency and stability robustness by studying this tradeoff curve. The proposed framework not only leads to the design of an optimal controller, but also enables a fair comparison among different interaction controllers. In order to demonstrate the practical use of the proposed approach, integer and fractional order admittance controllers are studied as a case study and compared both analytically and experimentally. The experimental results validate the proposed design framework and show that the achievable transparency under fractional order admittance controller is higher than that of integer order one, when both controllers are designed to ensure the same level of stability robustness.