In vitro ketone‐supported mitochondrial respiration is minimal when other substrates are readily available in cardiac and skeletal muscle

• Published in: The Journal of physiology Vol. 598; no. 21; pp. 4869 - 4885
• Main Authors: Petrick, Heather L., Brunetta, Henver S., Pignanelli, Chris, Nunes, Everson A., Loon, Luc J. C., Burr, Jamie F., Holloway, Graham P.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: England Wiley Subscription Services, Inc 01.11.2020
• Subjects: Animals; bioenergetics; Cardiac muscle; ketone bodies; Ketone Bodies - metabolism; Ketones; Lithium; metabolism; Mitochondria; Muscle, Skeletal - metabolism; Oxidation; Oxidative phosphorylation; Phosphorylation; Pyruvic acid; Rats; Respiration; Skeletal muscle; Ventricle; ketone bodies; metabolism; bioenergetics; mitochondria
• ISSN: 0022-3751; 1469-7793
• DOI: 10.1113/JP280032

Key points Ketone bodies are proposed to represent an alternative fuel source driving energy production, particularly during exercise. Biologically, the extent to which mitochondria utilize ketone bodies compared to other substrates remains unknown. We demonstrate in vitro that maximal mitochondrial respiration supported by ketone bodies is low when compared to carbohydrate‐derived substrates in the left ventricle and red gastrocnemius muscle from rodents, and in human skeletal muscle. When considering intramuscular concentrations of ketone bodies and the presence of other carbohydrate and lipid substrates, biological rates of mitochondrial respiration supported by ketone bodies are predicted to be minimal. At the mitochondrial level, it is therefore unlikely that ketone bodies are an important source for energy production in cardiac and skeletal muscle, particularly when other substrates are readily available. Ketone bodies (KB) have recently gained popularity as an alternative fuel source to support mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation and enhance exercise performance. However, given the low activity of ketolytic enzymes and potential inhibition from carbohydrate oxidation, it remains unknown if KBs can contribute to energy production. We therefore determined the ability of KBs (sodium dl‐β‐hydroxybutyrate, β‐HB; lithium acetoacetate, AcAc) to stimulate in vitro mitochondrial respiration in the left ventricle (LV) and red gastrocnemius (RG) of rats, and in human vastus lateralis. Compared to pyruvate, the ability of KBs to maximally drive respiration was low in isolated mitochondria and permeabilized fibres (PmFb) from the LV (∼30–35% of pyruvate), RG (∼10–30%), and human vastus lateralis (∼2–10%). In PmFb, the concentration of KBs required to half‐maximally drive respiration (LV: 889 µm β‐HB, 801 µm AcAc; RG: 782 µm β‐HB, 267 µm AcAc) were greater than KB content representative of the muscle microenvironment (∼100 µm). This would predict low rates (∼1–4% of pyruvate) of biological KB‐supported respiration in the LV (8–14 pmol s−1 mg−1) and RG (3–6 pmol s−1 mg−1) at rest and following exercise. Moreover, KBs did not increase respiration in the presence of saturating pyruvate, submaximal pyruvate (100 µm) reduced the ability of physiological β‐HB to drive respiration, and addition of other intracellular substrates (succinate + palmitoylcarnitine) decreased maximal KB‐supported respiration. As a result, product inhibition is likely to limit KB oxidation. Altogether, the ability of KBs to drive mitochondrial respiration is minimal and they are likely to be outcompeted by other substrates, compromising their use as an important energy source. Key points Ketone bodies are proposed to represent an alternative fuel source driving energy production, particularly during exercise. Biologically, the extent to which mitochondria utilize ketone bodies compared to other substrates remains unknown. We demonstrate in vitro that maximal mitochondrial respiration supported by ketone bodies is low when compared to carbohydrate‐derived substrates in the left ventricle and red gastrocnemius muscle from rodents, and in human skeletal muscle. When considering intramuscular concentrations of ketone bodies and the presence of other carbohydrate and lipid substrates, biological rates of mitochondrial respiration supported by ketone bodies are predicted to be minimal. At the mitochondrial level, it is therefore unlikely that ketone bodies are an important source for energy production in cardiac and skeletal muscle, particularly when other substrates are readily available.