The metaphysics of financial performance in financial accounting

• Published in: Philosophy of management Vol. 22; no. 2; pp. 205 - 226
• Main Author: Rutherford, Brian A
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Cham Springer International Publishing 01.06.2023; Springer Nature B.V
• Subjects: Accounting; Business and Management; Education; Equity; Financial performance; Financial reporting; Financial statements; International Political Economy; Metaphysics; Ontology; Philosophy; Pragmatism; Quality of Life Research; Conceptual framework; Financial performance; Pragmatism; Individuation; Classification
• ISSN: 1740-3812; 2052-9597
• DOI: 10.1007/s40926-022-00217-0

This paper argues that the metaphysics of financial performance in the conceptual framework employed by accounting standard-setters is incoherent: income and expenses cannot, as the framework holds, both be independent elements of financial statements, identified from underlying events, tested for recognition and measured by discrete acts, separately from the identification, testing and measurement of other elements and satisfy the analytical relationship between performance and position embraced by the framework. An alternative conceptualisation is proposed, under which income and expenses are part of a wider system of classifying all changes in assets and liabilities, measured indirectly. This approach improves the metaphysical coherence, and thus the intellectual strength, of the framework project; while it leaves the measurement of financial performance unchanged, by emphasising the importance of classification, it invites further attention to the presentation of financial performance, with the potential for improving the usefulness of disclosures.