Difficult airway intubation simulation using Bonfils fiberscope and rigid fiberscope for surgical training

• Published in: International journal of pediatric otorhinolaryngology Vol. 105; pp. 171 - 175
• Main Authors: Dharmarajan, Harish, Liu, Yi-Chun Carol, Hippard, Helena Karlberg, Chandy, Binoy
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Ireland Elsevier B.V 01.02.2018
• Subjects: Anterior larynx; Bonfils; Pediatric airway; Pierre Robin Sequence; Rigid fiberscope; Simulation; Rigid fiberscope; Bonfils; Pediatric airway; Simulation; Pierre Robin Sequence; Anterior larynx
• ISSN: 0165-5876; 1872-8464
• DOI: 10.1016/j.ijporl.2017.12.023

Pediatric otolaryngologists are frequently called to assist in difficult airway management in newborns with Pierre Robin Sequence (PRS) who have microretrognathia, glossoptosis, and an anterior larynx. The Bonfils fiberscope (BF) is a curved rigid scope designed to provide superior visualization in the anterior larynx. (1) to assess whether BF provides an improvement in intubation success rate, time to intubation, or airway visualization as compared to rigid fiberscope (RF) in a difficult airway simulation setting and (2) to determine whether a training program for BF can improve time to intubation through practice trials. Six right-handed trainees completed five trials on each of the three following airway models using the BF and RF: normal anatomy, anterior larynx and PRS. The normal larynx model was intubated only with RF. Main outcome measures were the time needed for tracheal intubation and Cormack–Lehane classification (1–4). The majority of the intubation trials showed a statistically significant difference between first and last completion times (p < .05) suggesting construct validity. Only the anterior larynx trials with BF did not demonstrate an improvement in time to intubation between first and last attempts (p < .3125). For the PRS retrognathia model, there was no statistically significant difference in time to intubation between using the BF and the RF (p < .44); in the anterior larynx model, the RF yielded a faster time to intubation than the BF on the final trial attempts (p < .0313). By Cormack–Lehane classification measures, laryngeal visualization by the BF was better than RF in the PRS manikin (p < .0022) while there was no significant difference in grade scores for the anterior larynx manikin (p < .45). All six trainees reported an improved visualization of the larynx with the BF compared to the RF for both the anterior larynx and PRS manikins; at the end of the trial runs, all participants noted an improvement in comfort level using the BF. The difficult airway simulation model is feasible for surgical training. BF adds superior visualization of the anterior larynx in PRS. Otolaryngology training programs may include BF as a supplemental tool in addition to RF as a part of the airway equipment training since there is significant improvement in time to intubation with consecutive practice trials and superior laryngeal visualization.