Comparison of Ground Point Filtering Algorithms for High-Density Point Clouds Collected by Terrestrial LiDAR

• Published in: Remote sensing (Basel, Switzerland) Vol. 14; no. 19; p. 4776
• Main Authors: Bailey, Gene, Li, Yingkui, McKinney, Nathan, Yoder, Daniel, Wright, Wesley, Herrero, Hannah
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Basel MDPI AG 01.10.2022
• Subjects: Algorithms; Classification; cloth simulation filter; Datasets; Density; Denudation; Design; Filtration; Lasers; Lidar; micro-topographic change detection; modified slope-based filter; Neighborhoods; Parameters; Performance assessment; Performance evaluation; point cloud classification; random forest classifier; Scanners; Software; Soil erosion; terrestrial LiDAR; Three dimensional models; Topography; Vegetation
• ISSN: 2072-4292; 2072-4292
• DOI: 10.3390/rs14194776

Terrestrial LiDAR (light detection and ranging) has been used to quantify micro-topographic changes using high-density 3D point clouds in which extracting the ground surface is susceptible to off-terrain (OT) points. Various filtering algorithms are available in classifying ground and OT points, but additional research is needed to choose and implement a suitable algorithm for a given surface. This paper assesses the performance of three filtering algorithms in classifying terrestrial LiDAR point clouds: a cloth simulation filter (CSF), a modified slope-based filter (MSBF), and a random forest (RF) classifier, based on a typical use-case in quantifying soil erosion and surface denudation. A hillslope plot was scanned before and after removing vegetation to generate a test dataset of ground and OT points. Each algorithm was then tested against this dataset with various parameters/settings to obtain the highest performance. CSF produced the best classification with a Kappa value of 0.86, but its performance is highly influenced by the ‘time-step’ parameter. MSBF had the highest precision of 0.94 for ground point classification but the highest Kappa value of only 0.62. RF produced balanced classifications with the highest Kappa value of 0.75. This work provides valuable information in optimizing the parameters of the filtering algorithms to improve their performance in detecting micro-topographic changes.