Participation or legitimisation? Assessment of quality of participation in farmer learning video production in central Uganda

• Published in: The journal of agricultural education and extension Vol. 26; no. 3; pp. 253 - 268
• Main Authors: Bulenzibuto Tamubula, Irene, Sseguya, Haroon, Miiro, Richard, Okry, Florent
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Abingdon Routledge 26.05.2020; Taylor & Francis Ltd
• Subjects: Access to Education; Agricultural development; Agricultural Occupations; Agricultural Production; Communication Problems; Developing countries; Developing Nations; Expertise; farmer learning videos; farmer-to-farmer; Farming; Film Production; Focus Groups; Foreign Countries; Indigenous Knowledge; Instructional Films; LDCs; Learning; Nongovernmental Organizations; Participant Satisfaction; Participation; Planning; Product development; Quality; Quality assessment; Research design; Rural Extension; Selection; Uganda; User friendly products; Video communication; video production process; Video Technology; Vocational Interests; Uganda
• ISSN: 1389-224X; 1750-8622
• DOI: 10.1080/1389224X.2019.1690011

Purpose: This study assessed the quality of participation in farmer learning video (FLV) production by examining opportunities for actors' participation and the extent of incorporation of their interests. Design/methodology/approach: A qualitative case study research design was used through focus group discussions and interviews held with 5 key informants and 19 farmers involved in the production of 2 videos. We used the quality of participation analytical framework for analysis. Findings: Actors in FLV production were largely selected basing on interests and expertise in carrying out assigned tasks. The extent of actor participation in FLV production varied. Video experts made major decisions on video content and allocation of tasks while field officers and farmers largely participated in the filming stage. The incorporation of farmers' interests was curtailed by their limited participation in planning for FLV production. Further, farmers and field officers perceived that inadequate communication between and among them limited their contributions to FLV production. Practical implications: Choice of actors with the right expertise and providing opportunities for interactions of individual expertise to generate video content is essential. Further, effective communication among actors is important for enhancing actors' contributions and incorporation of their interests especially at the planning stage. Theoretical implications: Participation of end-users in product development should not only focus on their participation but also on the quality of that participation. Originality/value: Many developing countries have incorporated use of videos in agricultural development initiatives thereby necessitating the production of quality FLVs.