Relationships among Root–Shoot Ratio, Early Growth, and Health of Hybrid Poplar and Willow Clones Grown in Different Landfill Soils

• Published in: Forests Vol. 10; no. 1; p. 49
• Main Authors: Rogers, Elizabeth, Zalesny, Ronald, Hallett, Richard, Headlee, William, Wiese, Adam
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Basel MDPI AG 01.01.2019
• Subjects: Agricultural production; Allocations; Biomass; biomass production; Cloning; Ecosystem services; Ecosystems; Genotype & phenotype; Health; hybrids; Hydrocarbons; Landfill; Landfills; Leachates; Mineral oils; Nitrogen; Phytoremediation; phytotechnologies; Pollutants; Poplar; Productivity; Regression analysis; Soil contamination; Soils; Waste disposal sites; Waste treatment; Willow; New York; United States > US
• ISSN: 1999-4907; 1999-4907
• DOI: 10.3390/f10010049

Root–shoot allocation of biomass is an underrepresented criterion that could be used for tree selection in phytoremediation. We evaluated how root–shoot allocations relate to biomass production and overall health of poplar and willow clones grown in landfill soil treatments. Fifteen poplar clones and nine willows were grown in a greenhouse for 65 days in soils from five Wisconsin landfills and one greenhouse control. We tested for treatment, clone, and interaction differences in root–shoot ratio (RSR), health, and growth index, along with relationships between RSR with diameter, health, height, total biomass, and growth index. Treatments, clones, and their interactions were not significantly different for poplar RSR, but willow clones differed (p = 0.0049). Health significantly varied among willow clones (p < 0.0001) and among the clone × treatment interaction for poplars (p = 0.0196). Analysis of means showed that willow clones ‘Allegany’ and ‘S365’ exhibited 28% and 21% significantly greater health scores than the overall mean, respectively. Root–shoot ratio was not significantly correlated with health in either genus but was positively correlated with growth index for poplars, which was corroborated via regression analyses. Selecting clones based on a combination of biomass allocation, health, and growth indices may be useful for using phyto-recurrent selection to satisfy site-specific ecosystem services objectives.