Assessing the phosphorus demand in European agricultural soils based on the Olsen method

• Published in: Journal of cleaner production Vol. 379; p. 134749
• Main Authors: Recena, Ramiro, García-López, Ana M., Quintero, José M., Skyttä, Annaliina, Ylivainio, Kari, Santner, Jakob, Buenemann, Else, Delgado, Antonio
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Elsevier Ltd 15.12.2022
• Subjects: Circular economy; Fertilizer; Soil P test; Threshold value; Threshold value; MAE; Soil P test; Circular economy; SPT; GLM; AIC; RMSE; LOOCV; Fertilizer
• ISSN: 0959-6526; 1879-1786
• DOI: 10.1016/j.jclepro.2022.134749

Overcoming the consequences of future scarcity of P is crucial to ensure agriculture sustainability. This requires decision-making processes depending on data on the P status of agricultural fields, commonly conducted with soil P tests (SPTs), and efficient use of the resource on a societal scale following a circular economy approach. All this will decrease the P losses and the subsequent environmental impact. However, SPTs are not universal and, even for a given SPT, the definition of threshold values for fertilizer response is not accurate. This work aimed to define models to predict Olsen P threshold values, allowing the identification of P-responsive sites at the European scale as a basis for more accurate and sustainable P fertilization schemes based on a circular economy approach. To this end, a data set was compiled based on a literature review that describes the Olsen P threshold values for different crops under field conditions. Subsequently, an analysis of potential P fertilizer requirements was performed on agricultural soils of the European Union (EU) using the data set of the LUCAS project and how this need can be covered with a circular economy approach. Environmental factors were more relevant than crops to explain the variation in threshold values. A regression model involving soil pH and clay content and annual average rainfall as independent variables explained 61% of the variance in Olsen P threshold values. When soil pH and clay content were the only explanatory variables, the explained variance was 49%. This reveals the need to take into account factors related to P buffer and sorption capacity to estimate accurate threshold values. We detected that only 27.8% of EU cropland soils and 42.7% of grassland soils were P-responsive. We can conclude that a more precise allocation of the resource is possible in P-responsive sites and also that most of the European demand for P could be covered by recycling P from manure, wastewater, and municipal solid waste. •Identification of P-responsive sites is possible using a simple model for the estimation of Olsen P threshold values.•This will allow for a better allocation of P resources and more accurate estimates of P fertilizer rates.•Only 27.8% of croplands EU soils were P-responsive.•Most of the European P demand could be covered with a circular economy approach.•Results will contribute to agricultural sustainability and environmental performance in the use of P resource.