Persistence of tropical herbivores in temperate reefs constrains kelp resilience to cryptic habitats

• Published in: The Journal of ecology Vol. 109; no. 5; pp. 2081 - 2094
• Main Authors: Zarco‐Perello, Salvador, Bosch, Nestor E., Bennett, Scott, Vanderklift, Mat A., Wernberg, Thomas, Randall Hughes, A.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Oxford Blackwell Publishing Ltd 01.05.2021
• Subjects: Algae; Aquatic plants; Browsing; Canopies; Canopy; Climate change; Ecosystems; Global warming; Habitats; Herbivores; Herbivory; Juveniles; Kelp; kelp forest; Lagoons; Macrophytes; Marine ecosystems; Marine fishes; Nursery grounds; Open spaces; Populations; Propagules; Range extension; Recovery; Recruitment; Recruitment (fisheries); Reefs; refuge; Refuges; Refugia; Resilience; Restoration; Sea grasses; seagrass; Seaweeds; Substrata; Survival; temperate reefs; Tropical climate; Tropical forests; tropicalization; Turf
• ISSN: 0022-0477; 1365-2745
• DOI: 10.1111/1365-2745.13621

Global warming is facilitating the range expansion of tropical herbivores, causing a tropicalization of temperate marine ecosystems, where tropical herbivores can suppress habitat‐forming macrophytes, supporting the resilience of canopy‐free ecosystem states. However, currently we lack a thorough understanding of the mechanisms that, on one hand, support the persistence of tropical herbivores and on the other support the recovery of temperate foundation species in tropicalized ecosystems, a required knowledge to predict potential regime shifts and reversals to the baseline state of the ecosystem. This study tested processes behind the persistence of the tropicalization of temperate reefs which experienced a complete loss of their kelp forests and an influx of tropical herbivores following a marine heatwave in 2011. For this, we assessed the feedback mechanisms that maintain turf‐dominated states (recruitment of tropical herbivores, browsing and grazing rates and turf cover) and those that resist it (kelp recruitment, survival and reproductiveness). We found that the reefs remained tropicalized with high abundances of turf and tropical herbivores after 9 years from the regime shift. The rabbitfish Siganus fuscescens and the chub Kyphosus bigibbus were the most important herbivores whose persistence was supported by the adjacent reef lagoon, where seagrass meadows and the backreef habitats hosted juveniles of both species, particularly rabbitfish. Tropical herbivores exerted a strong top–down control on turf seaweed and kelp during herbivory assays, rapidly consuming kelp individuals in open areas. However, in topographical refuges in the reefs, herbivory was low and kelp individuals survived, with some having reproductive tissue. Synthesis. Our findings incorporate the importance of nursery grounds for tropical herbivores and herbivory refugia for kelp individuals into the tropicalization model, where the former increases the resilience of canopy‐free states and the latter might facilitate recovering kelp populations. The restoration of abundant warm‐resistant kelp populations in shelters could provide local sources of propagules to recolonize open spaces; however, our results suggest that the reduction of herbivory and the provision of turf‐free substratum would be necessary to boost the recovery of kelp forests. Our findings incorporate the importance of nursery grounds for range‐expanding tropical herbivores and herbivory refugia for kelp individuals into the tropicalization model of temperate reefs, where the former increases the resilience of canopy‐free states and the latter the resilience and the recovery of kelp forests. The restoration of abundant warm‐resistant kelp populations in shelters would provide local sources of propagules to recolonize open spaces; however, our results suggest that the reduction of herbivory and the provision of turf‐free substratum would be necessary to boost the recovery of kelp forests.