Chinese employees' interpersonal conflict management strategies

• Published in: The International journal of conflict management Vol. 23; no. 4; pp. 382 - 412
• Main Authors: Nguyen, Hannah-Hanh D, Yang, Jie
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Bowling Green Emerald Group Publishing Limited 28.09.2012
• Subjects: Conflict management; Cultural differences; Culture; Employees; Government executives; Management styles; Norms; Researchers; Social conflict; Socialization; Studies; Supervisors; Work experience; China; Organizational conflict; Chinese conflict management strategy; International organizational practices; Conflict resolution; Chinese people; Emic conflict management
• ISSN: 1044-4068; 1758-8545
• DOI: 10.1108/10444061211267272

Purpose - The main research purposes of this paper are to: conceptualize Chinese conflict management behaviors as contingent on the hierarchical relations of conflict parties in an organizational context; and investigate individual characteristics as moderators in this contingency framework.Design methodology approach - This emic study consisted of two steps: using nine subject matter experts to develop conflict scenarios and conflict management strategies, and using this instrument to collect data from 704 actual employees across China. Multinomial logistic analysis was used to analyze respondents' choice of strategies.Findings - The findings supported the hypotheses. Chinese role-playing a supervisor in a conflict with their subordinate tended to use direct, assertive strategies to resolve the conflict, but the results depended on age, education, gender, region and work experience. As a subordinate in a conflict with their supervisor, Chinese chose indirect, harmony-preserving strategies, particularly when they were older and more interaction adept. In a conflict with a peer, respondents used a broader spectrum of conflict management strategies, depending on their individual characteristics. No "best practices" were found or universal strategies adopted.Research limitations implications - The limitations include the lack of random sampling and a scenario-based method. The emic evidence for a contingency perspective of conflict resolution framework was provided. The conflict scenarios may be used in organizational training of conflict management.Originality value - Conflict scenarios and management strategies developed by local subject matter experts were used to evaluate Chinese workers' choices of conflict management strategies. The findings call for the re-conceptualization of conflict management strategies as a contingent and culture-specific construct.