Loss of coevolved basal and plastic responses to temperature may underlie trophic level host-parasitoid interactions under global change

• Published in: Biological control Vol. 118; pp. 44 - 54
• Main Authors: Machekano, Honest, Mvumi, Brighton M., Nyamukondiwa, Casper
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Elsevier Inc 01.03.2018
• Subjects: biogeography; biological control; Coevolution; Cotesia; global warming; heat; heat tolerance; herbivores; Host-natural enemy interactions; host-parasitoid relationships; insects; larvae; life history; natural enemies; parasitoids; Pest management; Phenotypic plasticity; Plutella xylostella; population dynamics; Southern Africa; survival rate; temperature; Thermal tolerance; trophic levels; Southern Africa; Host-natural enemy interactions; Phenotypic plasticity; Pest management; Coevolution; Thermal tolerance
• ISSN: 1049-9644; 1090-2112
• DOI: 10.1016/j.biocontrol.2017.12.005

•Cotesia vestalis exhibited reduced responses to temperature compared to Plutella xylostella.•Differential thermal responses may decouple coevolved host-parasitoid trophic interactions.•Decoupled thermal responses may offset ecological services of the parasitoid.•Microclimate temperature extremes subject C. vestalis to more thermal stress than P. xylostella.•Scope exists for thermal conditioning C. vestalis to improve temperature resilience. Climate change has complex impacts on insect life history traits, biogeography, survival, population dynamics and host-parasitoid seasonal phenologies that affect their synchrony. This is more pronounced in tropical southern Africa, where global warming may be relatively high. While some work on Plutella xylostella (L.) temperature tolerance has been reported, none focussed on African field insect populations and implications of trophic level interaction on biological control. To determine how climate change may affect coevolved trophic level interactions in a host-parasitoid trophic system, we compared the basal thermal tolerance of wild F1 populations of the parasitoid Cotesia vestalis (Haliday) to two life stages of herbivorous host P. xylostella (L.), a global economic pest of brassicas. Our results showed significantly lower C. vestalis critical thermal limits (P < .001) compared to the host. Similarly, the parasitoid heat knockdown time and chill comma recovery time tolerance were significantly lower than that of the host (P < .001). Lethal temperature assays revealed significantly lower survival rates (P < .001) for C. vestalis at both upper and lower temperature scales. Observed differential basal temperature responses may offset coevolved host-parasitoid synchrony through differences in host-parasitoid phenologies. Hence, future biological control programmes should aim at ‘creating’ resilience and climate-fitness in natural enemies through enhancing evolutionary potential to buffer them from the changing climate. This is the first report detailing trophic level thermal tolerance of P. xylostella and larval parasitoid, C. vestalis, focussing on ecological service implications of the field-wild parasitoid populations on the herbivore host.