Applied kinesiology unreliable for assessing nutrient status

Applied kinesiology is a technique used to assess nutritional status on the basis of the response of muscles to mechanical stress. In this study, 11 subjects were evaluated independently by three experienced applied kinesiologists for four nutrients (thiamin, zinc, vitamin A, and ascorbic acid). The...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Published inJournal of the American Dietetic Association Vol. 88; no. 6; p. 698
Main Authors Kenney, J.J. (Pritikin Longevity Center, Santa Monica, CA), Clemens, R, Forsythe, K.D
Format Journal Article
LanguageEnglish
Published United States 01.06.1988
Subjects
ABSORCION DE SUBSTANCIAS NUTRITIVAS
ABSORPTION DE SUBSTANCES NUTRITIVES
ADDITIF ALIMENTAIRE
ADITIVOS ALIMENTARIOS
Adult
Biomechanical Phenomena
Double-Blind Method
ESTADO NUTRICIONAL
ETAT NUTRITIONNEL
EVALUACION
EVALUATION
Female
FEMME
HOMBRES
HOMME
Humans
Isometric Contraction
Male
Movement
MUJERES
Muscles - physiology
NUTRICION HUMANA
Nutrition Disorders - diagnosis
NUTRITION HUMAINE
Nutritional Status
Vitamins - administration & dosage
Vitamins - blood
Online AccessGet more information

Cover

More Information
Summary:Applied kinesiology is a technique used to assess nutritional status on the basis of the response of muscles to mechanical stress. In this study, 11 subjects were evaluated independently by three experienced applied kinesiologists for four nutrients (thiamin, zinc, vitamin A, and ascorbic acid). The results obtained by those applied kinesiologists were compared with (a) one another, (b) standard laboratory tests for nutrient status, and (c) computerized isometric muscle testing. Statistical analysis yielded no significant interjudge reliability no significant correlation between the testers and standard biochemical tests for nutrient status, and no significant correlation between mechanical and manual determinations of relative muscle strength. In addition, the subjects were exposed in a double-blind fashion to supplements of thiamin, zinc, vitamin A, and ascorbic acid and two placebos (pectin and sucrose) and then re-tested. According to applied kinesiology theory, "weak" (indicating deficiency) muscles are strengthened when the subject is exposed to an appropriate nutritional supplement. Statistical analysis revealed no significant differences in the response to placebo, nutrients previously determined (by muscle testing) to be deficient, and nutrients previously determined (by muscle testing) to be adequate. Even though the number of subjects (11) and nutrients (4) tested was limited, the results of this study indicated that the use of applied kinesiology to evaluate nutrient status is no more useful than random guessing
Bibliography:S30
S01
9310294
ISSN:0002-8223
1878-3570
DOI:10.1016/S0002-8223(21)02038-1