Improving nitrate load simulation of the SWAT model in an extensively tile-drained watershed

• Published in: The Science of the total environment Vol. 904; p. 166331
• Main Authors: Kim, JungJin, Her, Younggu, Bhattarai, Rabin, Jeong, Hanseok
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Elsevier B.V 15.12.2023
• Subjects: Calibration; Nitrate; Sensitivity analysis; SWAT; Tile drainage; SWAT; Nitrate; Tile drainage; Sensitivity analysis; Calibration
• ISSN: 0048-9697; 1879-1026
• DOI: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2023.166331

Subsurface drainage systems are effective management practices employed to remove excess soil water, thereby improving soil aeration and crop productivity. However, these systems can also contribute to water quality issues by enhancing nitrate leaching and loads from agricultural fields. The Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) is commonly used to assess nitrate loads and long-term water quality impacts from agricultural watersheds. However, the current SWAT model oversimplifies nitrate transport processes by assuming a linear relationship between nitrate concentrations in tile flow and soil nitrate content. It also neglects the time lag between nitrate loading and transport with the flow. This study aimed to enhance the accuracy of nitrate load prediction by revising the subsurface drainage routine in the SWAT model. The revised routine was tested using flow and nitrate load measurements from a typical tile-drained watershed in east-central Illinois, U.S. The results demonstrated that the revised SWAT nitrate routine outperformed the current one in simulating nitrate transport at field and watershed scales. The revised routine improved the nitrate load prediction from an “unacceptable” to a “satisfactory” or “good” rating on the field scale. A sensitivity analysis conducted using the revised nitrate module showed the parameters directly associated with transpiration, groundwater discharge to the reach, the lag time of tile flow, and channel flow hydraulics were the most sensitive in nitrate load simulation. In addition, different tile depth scenarios were modeled to evaluate variation in the amount of surface runoff, tile flow, and nitrate loads by the surface flow and tile flow. The results of tile configuration scenarios agreed with understanding the tile flow process. The test results demonstrated the potential of the revised SWAT nitrate module as a tool to accurately evaluate the effects of tile drainage systems on water quality. [Display omitted] •The SWAT was revised to more precisely describe tile flow and nitrate loads.•The revised SWAT (SWAT-tile) was tested at both field and watershed scales.•The SWAT-tile outperformed the current SWAT in terms of prediction accuracy.•Parameters related to transport processes were found critical in the SWAT-tile.•Responses of the SWAT-tile to varying tile depths were hydrologically explicable.