Transnational adoption: reflections of the diaper diaspora : On reconfiguring race in the USA

• Published in: International journal of sociology and social policy Vol. 28; no. 11-12; pp. 440 - 457
• Main Author: QUIROZ, Pamela Anne
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Bingle Emerald 01.01.2008; Emerald Group Publishing Limited
• Subjects: Adoption; Asian Americans; Content analysis; Couples; Cultures and civilizations; Demographics; Demography; Diaspora; Ethnic relations. Racism; Families & family life; Family; General studies; Globalization; Hispanic Americans; Human rights; Minority & ethnic groups; Multiracial people; Parents & parenting; Policy; Race; Racialization; Racism; Segregation; Social Indicators; Social policy; Sociology; Sociology of the family. Age groups; Studies; Transnationalism; United States of America; White people; United States Of America; Choice; Adoption; Race; Transnationalism
• ISSN: 0144-333X; 1758-6720
• DOI: 10.1108/01443330810915170

Purpose - Popularly viewed as a humanitarian issue that transcends not only geopolitical boundaries of nationality but also sociopolitical borders of race, the ways in which transnational adoption reflects the racialization of children are often ignored. Because adoption is not a random process of family building but rather a purposive endeavor that involves the multiple dynamics of race, class, gender, sexual orientation and disability, it is important to recognize how trends in transnational adoption intersect with shifting racial structure. This paper aims to examine visas issued to orphans entering the USA from 1990-2005, international programs offered by US adoption agencies, and juxtaposes these with policies governing adoption in sending countries to illustrate how transnational adoption mirrors these emerging racial categories. Design/methodology/approach - Using the tripartite racial framework argued to characterize the shifting US racial structure, the author located adoptions in the top 20 sending countries to the USA for the past 16 years within this framework to assess how patterns of transnational adoption reflect the shifting US racial structure. To try to assess the extent to which adoptive parent 'demand' intersects with agency programs and the policies of other countries, the author also performed a content analysis of an online adoption directory with 236 private adoption agencies (120 of which maintained (international adoption programs) and US Department of State data on adoption policies of the top 20 sending countries. Findings - Transnational adoption patterns for the past 16 years lend support to the argument of a shifting racial structure and mirror the tripartite system described by Bonilla-Silva. For the past 16 years the majority of adoptions have been either from the White or Honorary White categories whereas 20 per cent of adoptions have been from the Collective Black category. While policies of sending countries no doubt factor into which programs are offered by US private agencies, Department of State information suggests that the restrictiveness of countries' adoption policies cannot by itself explain which countries are in the top 20. A significant part of this reciprocal process must include a focus on 'demand' to explain who gets adopted. Data on transnational patterns of adoption illustrate all too clearly which children are preferred, aligning with the emerging Latin American-like racial hierarchy in the USA. Originality/value - To the author's knowledge, this application has not been attempted nor has anyone considered adoption (domestic or transnational) as another social indicator of intimacy (albeit for a relatively small segment of the population). Adapted from the source document.