The match-up hypotheses revisited: matching social judgments and advertising messaging in celebrity endorsements

• Published in: European journal of marketing Vol. 56; no. 3; pp. 869 - 898
• Main Authors: Bauer, Brittney C., Carlson, Brad D., Johnson, Clark D.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Bradford Emerald Publishing Limited 06.04.2022; Emerald Group Publishing Limited
• Subjects: Advertising; Aniston, Jennifer; Between-subjects design; Celebrities; Consumers; Endorsements; Hypotheses; Marketing; Perceptions; User generated content; Stereotype content model; Advertising messaging; Celebrity endorsement; Social judgments
• ISSN: 0309-0566; 1758-7123; 0309-0566
• DOI: 10.1108/EJM-07-2020-0541

Purpose Although endorsers are thought to be highly effective when they match-up with a product, the current understanding of endorser match-up offers little insight for distinctions between equally attractive and trustworthy endorsers who have equivalent expertise in the product category, yet still diverge in their performance. Therefore, the main purpose of this research is to understand how a match between social judgments (i.e. warmth vs competence) of a celebrity endorser and specific advertising appeals (i.e. symbolic vs utilitarian) can improve consumer responses to an endorsement. Design/methodology/approach A preliminary study empirically distinguishes perceptions of warmth and competence from prevailing celebrity endorser evaluative criteria. Then, the authors conduct multiple 2 (warmth vs competence) × 2 (symbolic vs utilitarian) between-subjects experiments to demonstrate the effect of matching social judgments and advertising messaging, across celebrity genders (i.e. male and female), forms of marketing communications (i.e. print ads and interactive online ads) and types of brands (i.e. well-established and new/unknown). Findings The findings demonstrate that matching celebrity endorser social judgments with the appropriate type of advertising messaging positively influences consumer response to the brand for both male and female endorsers. Additionally, despite a commonly held belief that celebrity endorsements are more effective at changing attitudes than actual behaviors, for interactive online ads, the authors find that the match strategy can motivate consumer response through two different pathways. For well-established brands, the match improves overall brand response predominately through cognitive and behavioral mechanisms. Alternatively, for new or unknown brands, the match initially impacts affective responses, which are subsequently related to consumers shopping a brand’s product category, rating a brand higher in customer recommendations, choosing a brand’s products over top competitors and paying more for the brand’s offerings. Originality/value The main contribution of this research is the demonstrated support for an alternative and effective application of the match-up hypothesis, based on a fit between the endorser and the advertising messaging itself.