Influence of three-dimensionality on propulsive flapping

• Published in: Journal of fluid mechanics Vol. 886
• Main Authors: Zurman-Nasution, A. N., Ganapathisubramani, B., Weymouth, G. D.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Cambridge Cambridge University Press 10.03.2020
• Subjects: Amplitude; Amplitudes; Angle of attack; Animals; Bias; Computational fluid dynamics; Computer simulation; Dimensions; Experiments; Flapping; Flight; Fluid flow; Foils (structural shapes); Heaving; Kinematics; Pitching; Reynolds number; Simulation; Stability; Swimming; Three dimensional flow; Three dimensional motion; Vortex shedding; Vortices
• ISSN: 0022-1120; 1469-7645
• DOI: 10.1017/jfm.2019.1078

Propulsive flapping foils are widely studied in the development of swimming and flying animal-like autonomous systems. Numerical studies in this topic are mainly two-dimensional (2-D) studies, as they are quicker and cheaper, but this inhibits the three-dimensional (3-D) evolution of the shed vortices from leading and trailing edges. In this work, we examine the similarities and differences between 2-D and 3-D simulations through a case study in order to evaluate the efficacy and limitations of using 2-D simulations to describe a 3-D system. We simulate an infinite-span NACA0016 foil in both two and three dimensions at a Reynolds number of 5300 and an angle of attack of 10 ° . The foil is subject to prescribed heaving and pitching kinematics with varying trailing-edge deflection amplitude $A$ . Our primary finding is that the flow and forces are effectively 2-D at intermediate amplitude-based Strouhal numbers ( $St_{A}=2Af/U$ , where $U$ is the free-stream velocity and $f$ is the flapping frequency), $St_{A}\approx 0.3$ for heaving, $St_{A}\approx 0.3{-}0.6$ for pitching and $St_{A}\approx 0.15{-}0.45$ for coupled motion, while 3-D effects dominate outside of these ranges. These 2-D regions begin when the fluid energy induced by the flapping motion overcomes the 3-D vortex shedding found on a stationary foil, and the flow reverts back to 3-D when the strength of the shed vortices overwhelms the stabilising influence of viscous dissipation. These results indicate that 3-D to 2-D transitions or vice versa are a balance between the strength and stability of leading/trailing-edge vortices and the flapping energy. However, 2-D simulations can still be used for flapping flight/swimming studies provided that the flapping amplitude/frequency is within a given range.