Discovering critical KPI factors from natural language in maintenance work orders

• Published in: Journal of intelligent manufacturing Vol. 33; no. 6; pp. 1859 - 1877
• Main Authors: Navinchandran, Madhusudanan, Sharp, Michael E., Brundage, Michael P., Sexton, Thurston B.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: New York Springer US 01.08.2022; Springer Nature B.V
• Subjects: Anomalies; Business and Management; Business metrics; Control; Data mining; Decision making; Documents; Environmental factors; Indicators; Investigations; Machines; Maintenance; Manufacturing; Mechatronics; Natural language; Natural language processing; Processes; Production; Robotics; Tacit knowledge; Text analysis; Workflow; Intelligence augmentation; Natural language processing; Maintenance; Key performance indicators; Artificial intelligence
• ISSN: 0956-5515; 1572-8145
• DOI: 10.1007/s10845-021-01772-5

Optimizing maintenance practices is a continuous process that must take into account the evolving state of the equipment, resources, workers, and more. To help streamline this process, facilities need a concise procedure for identifying critical tasks and assets that have major impact on the performance of maintenance activities. This work provides a process for making data investigations more effective by discovering influential equipment, actions, and other environmental factors from tacit knowledge within maintenance documents and reports. Traditional application of text analysis focuses on prediction and modeling of system state directly. Variation in domain data, quality, and managerial expectations prevent the creation of a generic method to do this with real industrial data. Instead, text analysis techniques can be applied to discover key factors within a system, which function as indicators for further, in-depth analysis. These factors can point investigators where to find good or bad behaviors, but do not explicitly perform any anomaly detection. This paper details an adaptable procedure tailored to maintenance and industrial settings for determining important named entities within natural language documents. The procedure in this paper utilizes natural language processing techniques to extract these terms or concepts from maintenance work orders and measure their influence on Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) as defined by managers and decision makers. We present a case study to demonstrate the developed workflow (algorithmic procedure) to identify terms associated with concepts or systems which have strong relationships with a selected KPI, such as time or cost. This proof of concept uses the length of time a Maintenance Work Order (MWO) remains open from creation to completion as the relevant performance indicator. By identifying tasks, assets, and environments that have significant relevance to KPIs, planners and decision makers can more easily direct investigations to identify problem areas within a facility, better allocate resources, and guide more effective analysis for both monitoring and improving a facility. The output of the analysis workflow presented in this paper is not intended as a direct indicator of good or bad practices and assets, but instead is intended to be used to help direct and improve the effectiveness of investigations determining those. This workflow provides a preparatory investigation that both conditions the data, helps guide investigators into more productive and effective investigations of the latent information contained in human generated work logs, specifically the natural language recorded in MWOs. When this information preparing and gathering procedure is used in conjunction with other tacit knowledge or analysis tools it gives a more full picture of the efficiency and effectiveness of maintenance strategies. When properly applied, this methodology can identify pain points, highlight anomalous patterns, or verify expected outcomes of a facility’s maintenance strategy.