Mechanism of crescent-shaped and ring-shaped epidermal damage from laser hair removal with cryogen spray cooling

• Published in: Lasers in medical science Vol. 37; no. 9; pp. 3613 - 3619
• Main Authors: Imagawa, Kotaro, Kono, Taro, Komaba, Chieko, Yamamoto, Satoru, Tsunoda, Yotaro, Nemoto, Hitoshi, Hanai, Ushio, Groff, William F., Akamatsu, Tadashi
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: London Springer London 01.12.2022; Springer Nature B.V
• Subjects: Alexandrite; Cooling; Damage assessment; Dentistry; Epidermis; Fluence; Hair; Hair removal; Hyperpigmentation; Inflammation; Laser beams; Laser damage; Lasers; Medicine; Medicine & Public Health; Optical Devices; Optics; Original Article; Photonics; Quantum Optics; Shaving & shavers; Skin; Spray cooling; Thermal injury; Cryogen spray cooling; Ring-shaped hyperpigmentation; Crescent-shaped hyperpigmentation; Laser hair removal
• ISSN: 1435-604X; 0268-8921; 1435-604X
• DOI: 10.1007/s10103-022-03640-x

The safety and efficacy of laser hair removal have been well established through many clinical studies and through clinical use over the past 25 years. A laser hair removal device that protects the epidermis by utilizing cryogen spray cooling (CSC) is widely used internationally. In darker skin types, post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation (PIH) can occur after laser hair removal. In particular, laser hair removal with CSC is known to cause crescent-shaped or ring-shaped PIH. In this experiment, we report a visualization of this PIH mechanism. The laser used in this experiment is a 755-nm-long-pulsed alexandrite laser. Graph paper was treated with this laser to assess for thermal damage. We investigated changes in thermal damage due to differences in laser spot size, fluence output, and laser beam angle in relation to the graph paper. When using a spot size of 18 mm, we observed that higher fluences caused crescent-shaped thermal damage on the margins of the treated graph paper. It was also confirmed that when the hand piece is not held perpendicular to the skin, the laser-treated area is expanded and the CSC range is narrowed. These factors caused the area of thermal damage to widen. This widening causes ring-shaped thermal injury, leading to PIH. We treated graph paper using a hair removal laser with CSC to investigate the mechanism of crescent or ring-shaped thermal damage. Laser treatment on graph paper is effective as a test for defects in the CSC device. Factors that cause inadequate cooling, which leads to PIH, are large spot size, high fluence, not holding the laser hand piece perpendicular to the skin, and malfunctioning of CSC device.