Impacts of break crops and crop rotations on oilseed rape productivity: A review

• Published in: European journal of agronomy Vol. 101; pp. 63 - 77
• Main Authors: Hegewald, Hannes, Wensch-Dorendorf, Monika, Sieling, Klaus, Christen, Olaf
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Elsevier B.V 01.11.2018
• Subjects: Brassica napus L; Canola; Crop sequence; Diseases; Pests; Seed yield; Weeds; Brassica napus L; Seed yield; Canola; Pests; Crop sequence; Diseases; Weeds
• ISSN: 1161-0301; 1873-7331
• DOI: 10.1016/j.eja.2018.08.003

•This study reviews the results of global oilseed rape crop rotation experiments.•There is a worldwide trend to grow oilseed rape in shorter crop rotations.•Growing oilseed rape in short rotations resulted in yield losses across the major production areas.•High frequency oilseed rape cropping is related to increased disease levels, infestation with pests and high weed pressure.•There is an urgent need of diversified crop rotations for a sustainable oilseed rape production. Over the past decades, the economic benefit has prompted farmers to grow oilseed rape (OSR). Consequently, the global OSR production increased considerably, and today the crop is grown in shorter rotations than ever before. This development is evident for the major growing regions in the European Union, Canada, China, India and Australia. OSR crops usually yield more if grown after other species than when grown after OSR. Based on >550 comparisons, this review quantifies the yield benefit of OSR growing after a break crop with OSR after OSR as well as OSR growing after two-year and three-year breaks with continuous OSR. The mean yield increase varied with species of break crop and crop break intervals, ranging from 0.22 t ha−1 for OSR after barley to 0.46 t ha−1 after legumes, with a ranking of: barley < wheat < legumes. The mean yield increase of OSR after barley was consistent over varying yield levels of the following OSR, while it was inconsistent for OSR following wheat and legumes, with a lower yield response of OSR after wheat and a higher yield response of OSR after legumes at high yield levels. The mean additional yield after two successive break crops was 0.53 t ha-1, but depended on the yield of the following OSR crop and decreased at higher yield levels. A three-year break demonstrated a consistent yield benefit of 0.47 t ha-1 independent of the yield level of the succeeding OSR crop. We discuss the underlying mechanisms how different break crops and break intervals affect the seed yield of OSR, with a particular focus on diseases, pests and weeds. By quantifying the effects of different break crops and break intervals, it is our aim to provide the basis for decision to grow OSR in diverse rotations, to maintain the resources which contributed to the success of the OSR crop over the past decades, to exploit the full yield potential of the crop and to promote more sustainable OSR cropping systems.