Residual N effect of long-term applications of cattle slurry using winter wheat as test crop

• Published in: Field crops research Vol. 221; pp. 257 - 264
• Main Authors: Suarez-Tapia, Alfonso, Thomsen, Ingrid K., Rasmussen, Jim, Christensen, Bent T.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Elsevier B.V 15.05.2018
• Subjects: Animal manure; Askov-LTE; Mineral fertilizer; N response; NUE; NPK; DM; AM; Mineral fertilizer; Askov-LTE; N response; Nnew; Animal manure; PK; LTE; SLU; Nprev; NUE
• ISSN: 0378-4290; 1872-6852
• DOI: 10.1016/j.fcr.2017.10.013

•N response curves to test residual N effects of historical fertilization.•Long-term addition of mineral fertilizer N leaves little N residual effect.•A history of cattle slurry adds to grain yield and N offtake at harvest.•Mineralization of soil N interacts with crop response to mineral fertilizer N. Prediction of optimum fertilizer N requirements depends on reliable estimates of the residual value of N accumulated in soil from historical inputs of mineral fertilizers and animal manures. Using plots embedded in the Askov long-term experiments and treated since 1973 with different rates of N in cattle slurry (50, 100 and 150kg total-Nha−1 termed ½, 1 and 1½ SLU), we estimated the residual N value over two consecutive growth periods (2014/2015 and 2015/2016). We used winter wheat as test crop and soils with a history of mineral fertilizers only (1 PK (no N)) and 1 NPK (100kgNha−1) as reference treatments. In the test years, the customary nutrient treatments were withheld and each plot divided into six subplots randomly allocated increasing rates of mineral fertilizer N (0–250kgNha−1). The winter wheat yielded more in the first test year due to crop rotational effects and more benign climatic conditions, substantiating that more test years are needed when estimating residual N effects. The residual value of N added previously with NPK was negligible. In the first year, grain yields at N optimum were similar for NPK and SLU, but the amount of fertilizer N needed to reach optimum yield was 36kgNha−1 smaller for SLU than for NPK. In the second year, wheat grown on 1 NPK and 1 SLU soils showed similar yield optimum and N optimum. The same N optimum was found for 1½ SLU, but this treatment provided a higher grain yield. For unfertilized wheat, grain yields differed little between previous treatments (except for ½ SLU in the second test year). The average N-offtake in grain and straw did not differ between 1 PK and 1 NPK whereas wheat previously supported by 1 SLU removed 6.7kgNha−1 more. For unfertilized wheat, N offtakes in the first wheat crop were similar for PK and NPK; wheat grown on previous SLU plots removed more N. In the second test year differences were not significant. Excluding ½ SLU, the N use efficiency ranged from 0.60 to 0.74kgNkg−1N with little difference between previous treatments and years. Interactions between added N and historical N inputs illustrate that residual N effects are of little predictive value for productive cropping systems when based solely on unfertilized test crops.