Crowdsourced data as a strategic approach to include the human dimension in outdoor environmental quality assessments

• Published in: The Science of the total environment Vol. 953; p. 175925
• Main Authors: Cureau, Roberta Jacoby, Bou-Zeid, Elie, Pigliautile, Ilaria, Pisello, Anna Laura
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Netherlands Elsevier B.V 25.11.2024
• Subjects: Crowdsourced data; Environmental quality; Human comfort; Urban park; Wearable sensing; Urban park; Wearable sensing; Environmental quality; Crowdsourced data; Human comfort
• ISSN: 0048-9697; 1879-1026; 1879-1026
• DOI: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2024.175925

Outdoor environments extend living spaces as venues for various activities. Comfortable open public spaces can positively impact citizens' health and well-being, thereby improving the livability and resilience of cities. Considering the visitors' perception of these environments in comfort studies is crucial for ensuring their well-being and promoting the use of these spaces. However, traditional survey methods may be time- and resource-consuming to gather significant sample sizes, usually focusing on selected homogeneous samples. Crowdsourced data, then, has emerged as an alternative for assessing human perception, as it eases the collection of subjective feedback and potentially amplifies impact and inclusivity. This study presents a strategic approach for analyzing publicly available and willingly reported crowdsourced data from a digital mapping platform in outdoor comfort evaluations, aiming to verify whether these data are informative regarding environmental quality perception and to identify the environmental factors that people are most sensitive to. Urban parks located in New York City served as a case study. A multi-source, interdisciplinary information framework combined crowdsourced reviews with environmental data used to determine prevailing thermal conditions. Overall perception of parks was well-rated, revealing that their attractions and activities are probably the most appealing characteristics for park attendance. Regarding environmental perception, acoustic and thermal factors are clearly the most influential. Acoustics were well-rated, while the main aspect regarding the thermal domain is the recognition of shading as a mitigator for hot conditions. Environmental data provided complementary insights, particularly concerning the range of thermal sensations experienced in urban parks. The findings confirm that willingly reported crowdsourced data can provide valuable insights into urban crowd environmental perception, presenting a potentially suitable and effective method to include the human perspective in environmental quality assessments, as well as to evaluate and predict environmental-related risks. [Display omitted] •Application of crowdsourced reviews in outdoor comfort assessments was studied.•Acoustic and thermal are the most noticeable and highly rated aspects.•Reviews and wearable data show the relevance of providing varied thermal sensations.•New approach provides distinct insights into comfort and community vulnerabilities.