North Korean women entrepreneurs learning from failure

• Published in: International review of education Vol. 69; no. 1-2; pp. 207 - 226
• Main Authors: Choi, Jinhee, Prins, Esther
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Dordrecht Springer Netherlands 01.04.2023; Springer; Springer Nature B.V
• Subjects: Adjustment; Adult Education; Adult Learning; Cafes; Dining Facilities; Disadvantaged; Education; Employees; Entrepreneurs; Entrepreneurship; Ethnographic research; Ethnography; Everyday life; Failure; Females; Foreign Countries; Immigrants; International and Comparative Education; Interviews; Learning; Legal Problems; Migrants; Original Paper; Restaurants; Situated Learning; Social Adjustment; Trust (Psychology); Women; Work Environment; Work Experience; Workplaces; South Korea; North Korea; Adult learning; Situated learning; Entrepreneurship; Migration studies; Workplace learning; Learning from failure; North Korean migrants
• ISSN: 0020-8566; 1573-0638
• DOI: 10.1007/s11159-023-09994-w

Migrants’ workplace experiences in their host society, including failure, shape their social adjustment, yet how migrants learn from failures is under-investigated. The study presented here examined how North Korean migrants struggling for a foothold in South Korea sought to learn from failures in their workplaces and everyday life. The article draws on nine months of ethnographic research in South Korean restaurants and cafés employing North Korean migrants. Data sources include informal conversations and loosely structured interviews with five purposefully selected women who started, or planned to start, their own enterprise. The findings reveal that these migrants perceived failure in five interrelated spheres: financial, relational, physical, psychological and professional. Participants developed perspectives to understand failure as an integral part of learning in a new society and adopting unfamiliar role expectations and responsibilities. They also applied knowledge they had acquired through their failures to change their approach to their career and to strengthen their personal and business capacity to obtain a legitimate social position. Paradoxically, failures that were beyond their control, such as legal problems, created opportunities to receive practical support from, and increase trust in, South Koreans. In addition to challenging the discourse that portrays North Korean migrants as deficient, these findings contribute to adult education scholarship on migrants’ situated learning in their host societies.