Efficacy of chlorine-based disinfectants to control Legionella within premise plumbing systems

• Published in: Water research (Oxford) Vol. 259; p. 121794
• Main Authors: Xi, Hao, Ross, Kirstin E., Hinds, Jason, Molino, Paul J., Whiley, Harriet
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: England Elsevier Ltd 01.08.2024
• Subjects: Building water; Chloramine; Chloramines - pharmacology; Chlorine - pharmacology; Chlorine Compounds - pharmacology; Disinfectants - pharmacology; Disinfection - methods; Engineered water system; Heated water; L. pneumophila; Legionella - drug effects; Oxides - pharmacology; Potable water; Warm water; Water Microbiology; Water Purification - methods; Water Supply; Chloramine; L. pneumophila; Engineered water system; Heated water; Building water; Warm water; Potable water
• ISSN: 0043-1354; 1879-2448; 1879-2448
• DOI: 10.1016/j.watres.2024.121794

•Field studies comparing disinfectants rank the typical efficacy against Legionella as chloramine > chlorine dioxide > chlorine.•Disinfection concentration on its own is not the deciding factor for the disinfectant efficacy against Legionella.•A total of 16 different factors potentially influenced the antibacterial efficacy of the chlorine-based disinfectants.•A total of 21 factors were identified as influencing the rate of decay of disinfectants in premise plumbing systems.•Future research is needed to measure and model these factors in premise plumbing systems to improve Legionella control. Legionella is an opportunistic waterborne pathogen that causes Legionnaires’ disease. It poses a significant public health risk, especially to vulnerable populations in health care facilities. It is ubiquitous in manufactured water systems and is transmitted via inhalation or aspiration of aerosols/water droplets generated from water fixtures (e.g., showers and hand basins). As such, the effective management of premise plumbing systems (building water systems) in health care facilities is essential for reducing the risk of Legionnaires’ disease. Chemical disinfection is a commonly used control method and chlorine-based disinfectants, including chlorine, chloramine, and chlorine dioxide, have been used for over a century. However, the effectiveness of these disinfectants in premise plumbing systems is affected by various interconnected factors that can make it challenging to maintain effective disinfection. This systematic literature review identifies all studies that have examined the factors impacting the efficacy and decay of chlorine-based disinfectant within premise plumbing systems. A total of 117 field and laboratory-based studies were identified and included in this review. A total of 20 studies directly compared the effectiveness of the different chlorine-based disinfectants. The findings from these studies ranked the typical effectiveness as follows: chloramine > chlorine dioxide > chlorine. A total of 26 factors were identified across 117 studies as influencing the efficacy and decay of disinfectants in premise plumbing systems. These factors were sorted into categories of operational factors that are changed by the operation of water devices and fixtures (such as stagnation, temperature, water velocity), evolving factors which are changed in-directly (such as disinfectant concentration, Legionella disinfectant resistance, Legionella growth, season, biofilm and microbe, protozoa, nitrification, total organic carbon(TOC), pH, dissolved oxygen(DO), hardness, ammonia, and sediment and pipe deposit) and stable factors that are not often changed(such as disinfectant type, pipe material, pipe size, pipe age, water recirculating, softener, corrosion inhibitor, automatic sensor tap, building floor, and construction activity). A factor-effect map of each of these factors and whether they have a positive or negative association with disinfection efficacy against Legionella in premise plumbing systems is presented. It was also found that evaluating the effectiveness of chlorine disinfection as a water risk management strategy is further complicated by varying disinfection resistance of Legionella species and the form of Legionella (culturable/viable but non culturable, free living/biofilm associated, intracellular replication within amoeba hosts). Future research is needed that utilises sensors and other approaches to measure these key factors (such as pH, temperature, stagnation, water age and disinfection residual) in real time throughout premise plumbing systems. This information will support the development of improved models to predict disinfection within premise plumbing systems. The findings from this study will inform the use of chlorine-based disinfection within premise plumbing systems to reduce the risk of Legionnaires disease. [Display omitted]