Applying situational analysis to examine the impact of VOICES on people experiencing multiple disadvantage

• Published in: Housing, care and support Vol. 25; no. 3/4; pp. 204 - 222
• Main Authors: Spyropoulos, Konstantinos, Gidlow, Christopher James, McCormack, Fiona, Meakin, Andy, Hine, Rachele, Fedorowicz, Sophia
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Brighton Emerald Publishing Limited 25.11.2022; Emerald Group Publishing Limited
• Subjects: Consumers; Customer services; Customers; Empowerment; Equality; Evaluation research; Homeless people; Mapping; Marginality; Research methodology; Stigma; Voices; Failure demand; Housing First; Fair access; Systems thinking; Situational analysis; Multiple disadvantage
• ISSN: 1460-8790; 1460-8790; 2042-8375
• DOI: 10.1108/HCS-02-2022-0006

Purpose This paper reports the use of situational analysis as a systems methodology to evaluate the voices of independence change and empowerment in the Stoke-on-Trent (VOICES) partnership project. Design/methodology/approach Using situational analysis and drawing on a range of secondary data sources, a three-stage conceptual mapping process provided a detailed picture of both the non-linear interlinkage and complexity of the local system that VOICES was working to influence, as well as the processes that shaped the experiences of those who act within the situation. Findings Data highlighted the systemic challenges facing VOICES customers (e.g. stigma and marginalisation and lack of legal literacy), progress made by VOICES in each of their priority areas and an overarching theme of VOICES promoting equity (rather than equality) to address failure demand in the system of support for people with multiple needs and disadvantage. Originality/value The authors present the novel application of situational analysis to demonstrate a substantial impact of VOICES while demonstrating the value of this methodology for complex systems thinking research and evaluation.