How dimensional analysis allows to go beyond Metzner–Otto concept for non-Newtonian fluids

• Published in: Reviews in chemical engineering Vol. 38; no. 4; pp. 407 - 429
• Main Authors: Delaplace, Guillaume, Jeantet, Romain, Grenville, Richard, Cuvelier, Gérard, Loubiere, Karine
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Berlin De Gruyter 25.05.2022; Walter de Gruyter GmbH
• Subjects: agitation process; Dimensional analysis; Impellers; Material properties; Metzner–Otto concept; Newtonian fluids; Newtonian liquids; Non Newtonian fluids; Ostwald ripening; Power measurement; Questions; Rheological properties; Shear rate; Shear thinning (liquids)
• ISSN: 0167-8299; 2191-0235
• DOI: 10.1515/revce-2020-0006

The concept of Metzner and Otto was initially developed for correlating power measurements in stirred vessels for shear-thinning fluids in the laminar regime with regard to those obtained for Newtonian liquids. To get this overlap, Metzner and Otto postulated and determined an “effective shear rate” which was proportional to the rotational speed of the impeller Although it was not based on a strong theoretical background, it was rapidly admitted as a practical engineering approach and was extended for seeking out a “Newtonian correspondence” with non-Newtonian results (i.e. different classes of fluids). This was applied in a variety of tank processes even for predicting heat transfer or mixing time, which stretches far away from the frame initially envisaged by Metzner and Otto themselves. This paper aimed to show how dimensional analysis offers a theoretically founded framework to address this issue without the experimental determination of effective quantities. This work also aimed to enlarge the underlying questions to any process in which a variable material property exists and impacts the process. For that purpose, the pending questions of Metzner and Otto concept were first reminded (i.e. dependence of the Metzner–Otto constant to rheological parameters, physical meaning of the effective shear rate, etc.). Then, the theoretical background underlying the dimensional analysis was described and applied to the case of variable material properties (including non-Newtonian fluids), by introducing in particular the concept of material similarity. Finally, two examples were proposed to demonstrate how the rigorous framework associated with the dimensional analysis is a powerful method to exceed the concept of Metzner and Otto and can be adapted beyond the Ostwald–de Waele power law model to a wide range of non-Newtonian fluids in various processes, without being restricted to batch reactor and laminar regime.