The COVID 19 Pandemic as a Moral Test for Society

• Published in: Studies in logic, grammar and rhetoric : the Journal of University of Bialystok Vol. 68; no. 1; pp. 79 - 98
• Main Authors: Breczko, Anetta, Breczko, Agata, Martinez, Rafael Antonio Lopez
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Sciendo 01.12.2023
• Subjects: COVID-19; Ethical Dilemmas; Pandemic; Quality of Life; Triage
• ISSN: 2199-6059; 2199-6059
• DOI: 10.2478/slgr-2023-0004

The COVID-19 pandemic brings up unprecedented challenges. Healthcare practitioners find themselves in an extraordinary, wartime-like situation and are obliged to apply triage on a daily basis. In this context, routine procedures prove insufficient and the redefinition of ethical practice guidelines becomes a necessity – leading not only to a shift in procedures, but also reshaping the very value of human life. This, in turn, triggers an axiological crisis, which exacerbates the tension between paradigms of sanctity and quality of life and the conflicting principles of egalitarianism and utilitarianism. Triage should not be limited to healthcare practice only: the concept can be extended to a macro-level where policymakers decide whether to prioritize human lives over livelihoods and economic health, impacting healthcare system capacity. The complexity of the challenges arising from the pandemic uncovers the urgent need to seek solutions from an integrated approach. In this paper, we offer a transdisciplinary view: we first define technical aspects of triage from the perspective of a healthcare professional. In the second part, we further analyze the problem of medical prioritization in the light of doctrinal findings related to the value of human life, and we show how and to what extent this philosophical debate is reflected in the emerging ethical guidelines in France, Spain, Italy, Belgium, Germany and Austria. Finally, we broaden the concept of triage, adding the “macro-economic” ingredient in our analysis and we present the results for selected European countries with special emphasis on the case of Poland.