Examining the Prevalence of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injuries on Artificial Turf Surfaces Compared to Natural Grass Surfaces in Athletes: A Scoping Review

• Published in: Curēus (Palo Alto, CA) Vol. 16; no. 7; p. e63770
• Main Authors: Kushner, Jared N, Swickley, Tomas, Bandi, Rishiraj, Lian, Jayson, Knecht, Michelle K, Sacca, Lea
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States Cureus Inc 03.07.2024
• Subjects: Artificial turf; Athletic shoes; Biomechanics; Cohort analysis; High school football; Joint and ligament injuries; Knee; Professional sports; Ratios; Secondary schools; Soccer; Sports injuries; Surveillance; United States > US; anterior cruciate ligament (acl); soccer; football; artificial turf; natural turf
• ISSN: 2168-8184; 2168-8184
• DOI: 10.7759/cureus.63770

The anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) is commonly injured in sports such as American football and soccer. It is currently unknown if ACL injuries are more prevalent on natural grass or artificial turf fields. The purpose of this scoping review is to analyze research studies evaluating the effect of the playing surface on the prevalence of ACL injuries. We hypothesize that athletes face a greater risk of suffering ACL injuries while playing on artificial turf compared to natural grass. Our team conducted a comprehensive literature review by screening three databases (PubMed, Embase, and Cochrane) that comprised a wide range of peer-reviewed articles on ACL injuries suffered on natural grass and artificial turf surfaces. Inclusion criteria consisted of epidemiological and cohort studies published after 1990 that were written in English and focused on athletes ranging in skill level from youth to professional. Exclusion criteria consisted of biomechanical studies, review articles, and papers that focused on injuries of structures other than the ACL. Bias was assessed with the MINORS criteria. Results were presented by injury rates, calculated ratios, and confidence intervals. The final analysis included nine papers published in peer-reviewed journals. Three of nine papers found that ACL injuries are more likely to occur on artificial turf than on natural grass. Three papers found that there is no difference in the prevalence of ACL injuries between surfaces and one paper stated that ACL injuries are more likely on natural grass than artificial turf. Two papers did not report confidence intervals for ratios comparing injury rates between playing surfaces. There is no consensus in the current literature regarding the prevalence of ACL injuries on artificial turf versus natural grass surfaces. The primary limitation of this study was that the papers used a variety of methods to compare rates of ACL injuries on artificial and natural surfaces, making comparisons between the nine papers difficult.