‘Hands on’, ‘hands off’ or ‘hands poised’? Exploring intrapartum midwifery decision making through ethnographic research

• Published in: Midwifery Vol. 137; p. 104105
• Main Authors: Gillman, Lindsay J, Drennan, Vari M, Marshall, Jayne E, Boaz, Annette
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Scotland Elsevier Ltd 01.10.2024
• Subjects: Adult; Anthropology, Cultural - methods; Childbirth; Clinical decision making; Decision Making; England; Female; Humans; Midwifery; Midwifery - methods; Nurse Midwives - psychology; Perineum; Perineum - injuries; Pregnancy; Qualitative Research; Threshold concept theory; England; Midwifery; Clinical decision making; Perineum; Childbirth; Threshold concept theory
• ISSN: 0266-6138; 1532-3099; 1532-3099
• DOI: 10.1016/j.midw.2024.104105

Injury to the perineal tissues during childbirth is a frequent occurrence with most women likely to experience perineal injury during a first birth which, in some cases, can lead to significant long-term morbidity. The techniques used to minimise perineal injury are frequently termed ‘hands on’ and ‘hands poised’ or ‘hands off’. These terms are often undefined and used inconsistently in the literature, making it difficult to identify the best available evidence to inform midwifery practice. This study aimed to answer the research questions: What do midwives do to minimise perineal injury during birth and what influences their decision-making? An ethnographic study was undertaken during 2016 in a maternity unit in the southeast of England. Data were collected through participant-observation, ethnographic and semi-structured interviews and analysed using thematic analysis, informed by the pedagogic theory of threshold concepts. 31 midwives participated in the study. Evidence-based decision-making to minimise perineal injury during birth was identified as a complex concept. Within the context of threshold concept theory, three main themes were identified that contributed to the complexity: troublesome language, troublesome knowledge, and troublesome environments. Midwifery decision-making in the context of minimising perineal injury during birth is more varied and conceptually complex than has been previously described. Identification of the various aspects of troublesomeness in this context suggests that this element of practice is a midwifery threshold concept. Addressing this within midwifery curricula and practice education to enable evidence-based decision-making is important.