In the Circle of Non-Vengeance Lev Shestov and Friedrich Nietzsche

• Published in: Russian studies in philosophy Vol. 55; no. 5; pp. 350 - 363
• Main Author: Sineokaya, Julia V.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Routledge 03.09.2017
• Subjects: eternal recurrence; existentialism; moral correlate of theistic voluntarism; mutual influence of Russian and Western philosophical thought; Nietzsche; non-vengeance; Shestov
• ISSN: 1061-1967; 1558-0431
• DOI: 10.1080/10611967.2017.1375793

The topic of this article is the principle of non-vengeance, or a denial of the spirit of revenge [der Geist der Rache - Ger.], and how it is conceptualized in Friedrich Nietzsche and Lev Shestov. Both thinkers make this principle central to their philosophical discussions. However, they have different motives and ways of realizing the principle in their theories. Nietzsche's approach is manifested in his idea of the eternal recurrence, while for Shestov, the principle is rooted in his interpretation of the biblical myth of "repealing the past evil." Nietzsche defines vengeance as the will to repeal a past misdeed. Only our own will, turning toward the past and reevaluating itself, can free us from the spirit of revenge. Shestov goes beyond Nietzsche, transforming a moral problem into a theodicy problem. Truth is in the power of an Almighty Creator, who is capable of repealing something that has existed before. The absolute freedom of an all-powerful God who by his own volition can at once repeal a past evil shall solve the problem of vengeance. This article attempts to show the evolution of the two philosophers' views on the problem of vengeance and non-vengeance, putting those views in the context of the key events in the thinkers' lives.