Standard Percent DNA Sequence Difference for Insects Does Not Predict Species Boundaries

• Published in: Journal of economic entomology Vol. 99; no. 4; pp. 1037 - 1045
• Main Author: Cognato, A.I
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: England 01.08.2006
• Subjects: Animals; DNA; Genetic Speciation; genetic variation; insect taxonomy; Insecta - genetics; insects; interspecific variation; intraspecific variation; literature reviews; mitochondrial DNA; molecular systematics; nucleotide sequences; phylogeny; sequence homology; sister species; taxonomy
• ISSN: 0022-0493; 1938-291X
• DOI: 10.1603/0022-0493-99.4.1037

Diagnosis and assessment of species boundaries of economically important insects are often problematic because of limited morphological and/or biological characters. DNA data can help to identify and revise species. Nonoverlapping intra- and interspecific sequence divergences are often used as evidence for species. Thus, the establishment of a standardized percent nucleotide divergence to predict species boundaries would aid in cases where species status is suspect. However, given variation in nucleotide mutation rates and species concepts, association between a standard percent sequence divergence and species is questionable. This review surveys the percent DNA sequence difference found between sister-species of economically important insects, to assess whether a standard divergence associates with all taxa. Sixty-two comparisons of intra- and interspecific pairwise DNA differences were made for mitochondrial and nuclear loci spanning families of Isoptera, Phthiraptera, Hemiptera, Coleoptera, Lepidoptera, Diptera, and Hymenoptera. Intra- and interspecific sequence divergences varied widely among insects, 0.04-26.0 and 1.0-30.7%, respectively. The ranges of intra- and interspecific sequence divergences overlapped in 28 of 62 comparisons. This implies that a standardized percent sequence divergence would fail to correctly diagnose species for 45% of the cases. Common occurrence of nonmonophyly among closely related species probably explains this observation. Nonmonophyly and overlap of intra- and interspecific divergences were significantly associated. The reviewed studies suggest that a standard percent sequence divergence does not predict species boundaries among economically important insects. DNA data can help best to predict species boundaries via its inclusion in nonphenetic phylogenetic analysis and subsequent systematic expert scrutiny.