Performance of an ultrasonic telemetry positioning system under varied environmental conditions

• Published in: Animal biotelemetry Vol. 2; no. 1; p. 15
• Main Authors: Steel, Anna E, Coates, Julia H, Hearn, Alex R, Klimley, A Peter
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: BioMed Central Ltd 01.10.2014
• ISSN: 2050-3385; 2050-3385
• DOI: 10.1186/2050-3385-2-15

BACKGROUND: Advances in ultrasonic telemetry, including the ability to accurately position a transmitter within an array of hydrophone receivers, have led to increased opportunities to investigate a broad spectrum of ecological questions in aquatic systems. The quality and efficiency of positioning a transmitter relies upon factors controlled by the researcher (for example, geometry of the receiver array) as well as environmental conditions (for example, water quality or environmental noise). While the physics of sound wave propagation are well understood, the high amount of environmental variability in and among aquatic habitats makes it difficult to predict exactly how any given ultrasonic signal will behave. To evaluate variability in system performance across different receiver arrays in diverse environments we present positional records for fixed-location tags recorded with a popular positioning array, the VEMCO Positioning System (VPS). Using these records we evaluate the relationships between system performance, measured as both horizontal positioning error and positioning efficiency, and user-controlled and environmental variables. We used generalized linear mixed models to assess performance at a coastal site, a site in a freshwater tidal estuary, and a riverine site. RESULTS: The positioning errors were similar across sites, with median errors ranging from 1.6 to 3.3 m. In contrast, there was large variation in positioning efficiency across sites, with poor positioning efficiency in the coastal habitat (7%), possibly due to high levels of bioacoustic noise, and moderate efficiency in the river (21%) and estuary habitats (27%). Our statistical models indicate that array geometry was consistently the most important predictor of positioning performance. Environmental noise and water movement also emerged as additional predictors of performance at several sites. CONCLUSIONS: The results provide insight into VPS performance capabilities and emphasize the importance of testing array geometries. Additionally, water quality parameters should be monitored and receiver mooring designs should be carefully considered before embarking upon a telemetry study. We hope this work will guide future researchers in creating more effective designs for positioning arrays, and facilitate the collection of high quality information about movement and behavior patterns of aquatic organisms.