Paradox reconsidered Methane oversaturation in well-oxygenated lake waters

• Published in: Limnology and oceanography Vol. 59; no. 1; pp. 275 - 284
• Main Authors: Tang, Kam W., McGinnis, Daniel F., Frindte, Katharina, Brüchert, Volker, Grossart, Hans-Peter
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Waco, TX John Wiley and Sons, Inc 01.01.2014; American Society of Limnology and Oceanography
• Subjects: Earth sciences; Earth, ocean, space; Exact sciences and technology; Hydrology; Hydrology. Hydrogeology; Marine and continental quaternary; Surficial geology; Central Europe; Europe; Germany; experimental studies; fresh-water environment; accumulation; nitrogen; thermocline; oxidation; concentration; methanogenesis; surface water; bottom water; photosynthesis; isotopes; fixation; methane; lakes; oxygen
• ISSN: 0024-3590; 1939-5590; 1939-5590
• DOI: 10.4319/lo.2014.59.1.0275

The widely reported paradox of methane oversaturation in oxygenated water challenges the prevailing paradigm that microbial methanogenesis only occurs under anoxic conditions. Using a combination of field sampling, incubation experiments, and modeling, we show that the recurring mid-water methane peak in Lake Stechlin, northeast Germany, was not dependent on methane input from the littoral zone or bottom sediment or on the presence of known micro-anoxic zones. The methane peak repeatedly overlapped with oxygen oversaturation in the seasonal thermocline. Incubation experiments and isotope analysis indicated active methane production, which was likely linked to photosynthesis and/or nitrogen fixation within the oxygenated water, whereas lessening of methane oxidation by light allowed accumulation of methane in the oxygen-rich upper layer. Estimated methane efflux from the surface water was up to 5 mmol m−2 d−1. Mid-water methane oversaturation was also observed in nine other lakes that collectively showed a strongly negative gradient of methane concentration within 0–20% dissolved oxygen (DO) in the bottom water, and a positive gradient within ≥ 20% DO in the upper water column. Further investigation into the responsible organisms and biochemical pathways will help improve our understanding of the global methane cycle.