How Fast or How Many? Sources of Intermittent Sediment Transport

• Published in: Geophysical research letters Vol. 50; no. 9
• Main Authors: Benavides, Santiago J., Deal, Eric, Venditti, Jeremy G., Bradley, Ryan, Zhang, Qiong, Kamrin, Ken, Perron, J. Taylor
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Washington John Wiley & Sons, Inc 16.05.2023; Wiley
• Subjects: bed load; Bursts; Earth surface; Flow velocity; Fluctuations; flume experiment; Flumes; Fluvial sediments; grain velocity; Grains; Gravel; Intermittency; Laboratories; Low flow; Movement; on‐off intermittency; Particle motion; River beds; Riverbeds; Rivers; Sand & gravel; Sediment; Sediment transport; stochastic; Stochastic models; Stochasticity; Transport rate
• ISSN: 0094-8276; 1944-8007
• DOI: 10.1029/2022GL101919

Near the threshold of grain motion, sediment transport is “on‐off” intermittent, characterized by large but rare bursts separated by long periods of low transport. Without models that can account for the effects of intermittency, measurements of average sediment flux can be in error by up to an order of magnitude. Despite its known presence and impact, it is not clear whether on‐off intermittency arises from the grain activity (the number of moving grains) or grain velocities, which together determine the sediment flux. We use laboratory flume experiments to show that the on‐off intermittency has its origins in the velocity distributions of grains that move by rolling along the bed, whereas grain activity is not on‐off intermittent. Incorporating the types of intermittency we identify into stochastic models of sediment transport could yield improved predictions of sediment flux, including physically based estimates of the uncertainty in time‐averaged sediment flux. Plain Language Summary Sediment, such as sand and gravel, is transported across the surface of the Earth and other planets by wind and water. Predicting the amount of sediment that can be transported given a certain flow rate is crucial for predicting how a landscape will change over time. For low flow rates, little to no grain motion occurs. Just beyond the flow rate required for motion, sediment transport occurs mostly in rare bursts. This so‐called “on‐off” intermittency creates difficulties when trying to measure the average transport rate, which must be done over longer time periods as the bursts become larger but less frequent. While on‐off intermittency has been identified in previous studies of sediment transport, there is currently no understanding of its physical origin. We use a series of experiments in a small laboratory river to show that the on‐off intermittency is due to large fluctuations in the speed of the grains rolling on the bed, and that the sediment transport becomes less bursty as more grains are lifted off the river bed and into the fluid. Our results will pave the way for better measurements and predictions of sediment transport in rivers. Key Points We use grain tracking data from laboratory experiments to separately study the statistics of grain velocities and grain activity We show that on‐off intermittency has its origins in the velocity distributions of grains, not in the grain activity On‐off intermittency comes from grains rolling on the bed, and disappears as more and more grains are lifted into the bulk of the flow