Noble gas insights into early impact delivery and volcanic outgassing to Earth's atmosphere: A limited role for the continental crust

• Published in: Earth and planetary science letters Vol. 609; no. C; p. 118083
• Main Authors: Zhang, Xinmu J., Avice, Guillaume, Parai, Rita
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Netherlands Elsevier B.V 01.05.2023; Elsevier
• Subjects: argon; continental crust; mantle outgassing; neon; noble gases; Sciences of the Universe; volatile delivery; volatile delivery; noble gases; argon; mantle outgassing; neon; continental crust
• ISSN: 0012-821X; 1385-013X
• DOI: 10.1016/j.epsl.2023.118083

Earth's atmosphere, crust and mantle have evolved together through continuous geochemical exchange throughout Earth's history. Constraints on the transport of volatile elements and compounds between these reservoirs are crucial for understanding how Earth could have stayed habitable for extended periods of time. Here we present a new forward model of He, Ne and Ar in the mantle, crust and atmosphere. We explore concentrations of noble gases at the end of accretion, bulk silicate Earth K/U ratios, crustal growth scenarios, and upper mantle processing rates throughout Earth's history. We search for parameter combinations that simultaneously satisfy observational constraints on present-day mantle 4He/3He and 40Ar/36Ar (sensitive to mantle outgassing and continental crust growth, which depletes the mantle of U, Th and K), atmospheric 20Ne/22Ne (which tracks the mix of outgassed vs. delivered Ne in the atmosphere), and atmospheric 40Ar/36Ar in the past and today (sensitive to volatile delivery, mantle outgassing and crustal growth). Leveraging this intertwined set of noble gas abundances and isotopic compositions yields new constraints on initial noble gas abundances in the mantle and on the proportions of atmospheric volatiles originating from delivery by impact degassing, mantle outgassing, and degassing of the continental crust. We find that atmospheric Ar isotopic evolution is primarily sensitive to the mantle processing rate history; the atmospheric Ar isotopic record should therefore not be used to reconstruct continental crust growth, but instead provides valuable insights into mantle processing rates. Our model predicts a measurably low 20Ne/22Ne ratio of ∼9.7 in Archean atmospheric samples. Most of atmospheric primordial 36Ar was directly delivered by chondritic bodies and not transferred to the atmosphere during an intense early episode of mantle outgassing. Nitrogen delivered by impact degassing could account for the present-day atmospheric nitrogen inventory. •We present a new forward model of He, Ne and Ar in the mantle, crust and atmosphere.•Atmospheric Ar isotopic evolution is primarily sensitive to mantle outgassing history.•The paleo-atmospheric Ar record cannot distinguish among crustal growth models.•Most of atmospheric primordial 36Ar was delivered by chondritic materials.•Chondritic delivery could account for the nitrogen budget of the atmosphere.