Purified Chlorine Dioxide as an Alternative to Chlorine Disinfection to Minimize Chlorate Formation During Postharvest Produce Washing

• Published in: Environmental science & technology Vol. 57; no. 32; pp. 12063 - 12071
• Main Authors: Suh, Min-Jeong, Simpson, Adam M.-A., Mitch, William A.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States American Chemical Society 15.08.2023
• Subjects: Ammonia; Antiseptics; Biomolecules; Brassica; Broccoli; Chlorate; Chlorine; Chlorine dioxide; Contamination; Disinfectants; Disinfection; Disinfection & disinfectants; Guidelines; Lipids; Low concentrations; Oleic acid; Physico-Chemical Treatment and Resource Recovery; Scavenging; Switching; Washing; chlorine dioxide; chlorate; disinfection byproducts; food; chlorine
• ISSN: 0013-936X; 1520-5851
• DOI: 10.1021/acs.est.3c00056

The washwater used to wash produce within postharvest washing facilities frequently contains high chlorine concentrations to prevent pathogen cross-contamination. To address concerns regarding the formation and uptake of chlorate (ClO3 –) into produce, this study evaluated whether switching to chlorine dioxide (ClO2) could reduce chlorate concentrations within the produce. Because ClO2 exhibits lower disinfectant demand than chlorine, substantially lower concentrations can be applied. However, ClO3 – can form through several pathways, particularly by reactions between ClO2 and the chlorine used to generate ClO2 via reaction with chlorite (ClO2 –) or chlorine that forms when ClO2 reacts with produce. This study demonstrates that purging ClO2 from the chlorine and ClO2 – mixture used for its generation through a trap containing ClO2 – can scavenge chlorine, substantially reducing ClO3 – concentrations in ClO2 stock solutions. Addition of low concentrations of ammonia to the produce washwater further reduced ClO3 – formation by binding the chlorine produced by ClO2 reactions with produce as inactive chloramines without scavenging ClO2. While chlorate concentrations in lettuce, kale, and broccoli exceeded regulatory guidelines during treatment with chlorine, ClO3 – concentrations were below regulatory guidelines for each of these vegetables when treated with ClO2 together with these two purification measures. Switching to purified ClO2 also reduced the concentrations of lipid-bound oleic acid chlorohydrins and protein-bound chlorotyrosines, which are exemplars of halogenated byproducts formed from disinfectant reactions with biomolecules within produce.