Evaluating Long-Term Treatment Performance and Cost of Nutrient Removal at Water Resource Recovery Facilities under Stochastic Influent Characteristics Using Artificial Neural Networks as Surrogates for Plantwide Modeling

• Published in: ACS ES&T engineering Vol. 1; no. 11; pp. 1517 - 1529
• Main Authors: Li, Shaobin, Emaminejad, Seyed Aryan, Aguiar, Samuel, Furneaux, Aliza, Cai, Ximing, Cusick, Roland D
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: American Chemical Society 12.11.2021
• Subjects: phosphorus recovery; Bardenpho enhanced biological phosphorus removal; techno-economic analysis; nutrient removal; machine learning
• ISSN: 2690-0645; 2690-0645
• DOI: 10.1021/acsestengg.1c00179

Integrated watershed modeling is needed to couple water resource recovery facilities (WRRFs) with agricultural management for holistic watershed nutrient management. Surrogate modeling can facilitate model coupling. This study applies artificial neural networks (ANNs) as surrogate models for WRRF models to efficiently evaluate the long-term treatment performance and cost under influent fluctuations. Specifically, we first developed five WRRFs, including activated sludge, activated sludge with chemical precipitation (ASCP), enhanced biological phosphorus removal (EBPR), EBPR with acetate addition (EBPR-A), and EBPR with struvite recovery (EBPR-S), in a high-fidelity simulation program (GPS-X). The five WRRFs were based on an existing plant that treats combined domestic and industrial wastewater. The ANNs have satisfactory performance in capturing nonlinear biological behaviors for all five WRRFs, even though the prediction performance (R-square) slightly decreases as the model complexity increases. We advanced ANNs application in WRRF models by simulating long-term (10-yr) performance with monthly influent fluctuations using ANNs trained by simulation data from steady-state models and evaluated their performance on Phosphorus (P) and Nitrogen (N) removal. EBPR-S shows the most resilience, while EBPR is more sensitive to influent characteristics impacted by stormwater inflow. When comparing life cycle costs of N and P removal for each layout over the 10-yr simulation period, EPBR-S is the most cost-effective alternative, highlighting both the operational and cost benefits of side-stream P recovery. By capturing both nonlinear behaviors of biological treatment and operating costs with computationally lean ANNs, this study provides a paradigm for integrating complex WRRF models within integrated watershed modeling frameworks.