Nonadditive Cytotoxicity in Select Disinfection Byproducts and Disinfected Secondary Effluents

• Published in: Environmental science & technology Vol. 58; no. 38; pp. 16795 - 16802
• Main Authors: Zhan, Yuehao, Zeng, Xuefeng, Chu, Wenhai, Wei, Xiao, Chen, Xiaohong, Liu, Bingjun, Hur, Kyu, Dong, Shengkun
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States American Chemical Society 10.09.2024
• Subjects: Antagonism; By products; Byproducts; Cytotoxicity; Disinfectants; Disinfection; Ecotoxicology and Public Health; Effluents; Fractionation; Mixing ratio; Mixtures; Synergism; Toxicity; Water pollution; synergism; additivity; disinfection byproducts (DBPs); cytotoxicity interaction; antagonism; mixture
• ISSN: 0013-936X; 1520-5851; 1520-5851
• DOI: 10.1021/acs.est.4c08404

Toxicity studies of water disinfection byproducts (DBPs) typically assume additive interactions. Coupling results from both the bottom-up cytotoxicity interaction approach by selecting six common DBPs and the top-down cytotoxicity fractionating the disinfected secondary effluent containing a much broader DBP selection, we demonstrated a novel effect of clear, nonadditive cytotoxicity at low chemical concentrations regardless of the number of DBP types involved. We revealed that the cytotoxicity interactions were influenced by the chemical’s type, concentration factor, and mixing ratio. For the bottom-up approach, the average combination indices (CIs) were 1.61 (chloracetamide + chloroacetonitrile, antagonism), 1.03 (bromoacetamide+bromoacetonitrile, near additivity), and 0.69 (iodoacetamide + iodoacetonitrile, synergism) across the DBPs’ concentration range of 10–4–10–7 M. These cytotoxicity interactions also varied with the components’ mixing ratios. For the top-down approach, we obtained two fractions of DBP mixtures from the disinfected secondary effluent using solvents of different polarities. The effect of the concentration on CI values was significant, with a maximum 43.1% relative deviation in CI from LC5 to LC95. The average CI values across the sample concentration range of 1–50 × (concentration factor) varied from 1.68 (antagonism) to 0.89 (slight synergism) as the ratio of mixture A increased. These results call for further research in prioritizing the forcing DBPs in mixtures.