Comparing the ethical challenges of forgoing tube feeding in American and Hong Kong patients with advanced dementia

• Published in: The Journal of nutrition, health & aging Vol. 11; no. 6; pp. 495 - 501
• Main Authors: PANG, M. C. S, VOLICER, L, CHUNG, P. M. B, CHUNG, Y. M. I, LEUNG, W. K. A, WHITES, P
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Paris Serdi 01.11.2007; Springer; Springer Nature B.V
• Subjects: Advance Directives; Aged; Aged, 80 and over; Biological and medical sciences; Boston - ethnology; Cross-Cultural Comparison; Decision Making; Dementia; Dementia - psychology; Dementia - therapy; Enteral Nutrition; Ethics, Clinical; Hong Kong - ethnology; Human physiology applied to population studies and life conditions. Human ecophysiology; Humans; Medical sciences; Nutritional survey. Food supply and nutritional requirement; Palliative Care - ethics; Palliative Care - methods; Patient Advocacy; Prevention and actions; Public health. Hygiene; Public health. Hygiene-occupational medicine; Specific populations (family, woman, child, elderly...); Hong Kong; Asia; United States; North America; China; America; Boston; Human; End-of-life care; American; Nutrition; Feeding tube; Patient; Ethics; tube feeding; ethical challenge; cultural study; Degenerative disease; Cultural aspect; Advanced dementia; Comparative study; Public health; Dementia
• ISSN: 1279-7707; 1760-4788

To develop a cross-cultural dialogue for enriching our understanding of how an ethical environment can be constructed in fostering tube-feeding decisions in patients with advanced dementia (AD). Drawing on the findings of two prospective case studies conducted in Boston and Hong Kong, this paper compares the decision-making patterns of forgoing tube feeding for AD patients and their emergent ethical dilemmas typified in a special dementia care unit in Boston (BCU) and a long-term care unit in Hong Kong (HKCU). Differences in forgoing tube feeding decision are delineated in the two places. No-tube-feeding practice was sustained in BCU in two ways: advance decision-making with respect paid to the patient's wishes and advance proxy decision-making focused on patient comfort. With life preservation as the prevailing value in the Hong Kong medical system, only strong family request coupled with medical evidence of patient's ability to continue hand-feeding that tube feeding would be discontinued. All patients died with some form of artificial feeding. A paradigm shift of values underpinning the practice of forgoing tube feeding in the context of palliative care is observed in three aspects. First, the emphasis on prognostication based on biomedical markers in predicting the length of survival is shifted to a focus on the "diagnosis of dying". Second, the overriding concern in conventional medical practice with preserving life is shifting to an overriding concern of "what is best for the patient." Third, in the last days of life, the conventional approach of "trying to do everything for the patient" had shifted from a technological to a relational one. Palliative measures for relieving discomfort and providing a peaceful and dignified environment in which the patient could die are the primary concern. Although the predominant medical culture in Hong Kong is biomedical, voices from the patients and family members challenge this conventional practice, and suggest that the alternative model may be a better choice.