A Clinical Study of Cancer Disclosure in Elderly Patients with Oral Cancer

Radical operation has been more frequently applied to elderly patients with oral cancer, as a rezult of recent development in medical treatment In general, informed consent is important for patients to choose their treatment, but in Japan elderly patients with cancer have not usually been informed o...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Published inRonen Shika Igaku Vol. 18; no. 1; pp. 28 - 35
Main Authors Komori, Takahide, Fujioka, Manabu, Yokoo, Satoshi, Shibuya, Yasuyuki, Umeda, Masahiro, Ishida, Yoshiki, Minamikawa, Tsutomu, Komatsubara, Hideki, Ojima, Yasutaka
Format Journal Article
LanguageJapanese
Published Japanese Society of Gerodontology 30.06.2003
一般社団法人 日本老年歯科医学会
Subjects
Online AccessGet full text
ISSN0914-3866
1884-7323
DOI10.11259/jsg1987.18.28

Cover

Abstract Radical operation has been more frequently applied to elderly patients with oral cancer, as a rezult of recent development in medical treatment In general, informed consent is important for patients to choose their treatment, but in Japan elderly patients with cancer have not usually been informed of their diagnosis. We studied elderly patients with oral cancer clinically, with special reference to the current trend of informed consent including cancer disclosure. The subjects of this study were 16 patients over 75 with oral cancer who were treated at our hospital between 2000 and 2002. Most of them had rather advanced cancer of stage III-IV. Fourteen of the 16 patients had some associated diseases, such as dimentia, hypertension, heart disease, cerebral infarction, lung disease, kidney disease, and rheumatism. Performance status (PS) was 0-1 in 6 patients, and 2-3 in 10 patients. 50% of the patients older than 75 years were informed of their diagnosis, while the disclosure rate for those younger than 75 years was 90.5%. The reasons for non-disclosure were mental disturbance by dimentia in 2 patients and patient's request in one, while in 5 patients cancer was not disclosed because of their advanced age, advanced stage, family's preference, or the former doctor's policy. Surgery was performed in 10 patients, radiotherapy in 1, and chemotherapy in 1. Four patients did not undergo any therapy because of their highly advanced stage, poor general condition, or of their family's refusal. Seven of 10 patients who underwent surgery survived in good health and recovered to the level of preoperative ADL, although 1 patient died of neck metastasis, 1 of distant metastasis, and 1 was not followed up.
AbstractList Radical operation has been more frequently applied to elderly patients with oral cancer, as a rezult of recent development in medical treatment In general, informed consent is important for patients to choose their treatment, but in Japan elderly patients with cancer have not usually been informed of their diagnosis. We studied elderly patients with oral cancer clinically, with special reference to the current trend of informed consent including cancer disclosure.The subjects of this study were 16 patients over 75 with oral cancer who were treated at our hospital between 2000 and 2002. Most of them had rather advanced cancer of stage III-IV. Fourteen of the 16 patients had some associated diseases, such as dimentia, hypertension, heart disease, cerebral infarction, lung disease, kidney disease, and rheumatism. Performance status (PS) was 0-1 in 6 patients, and 2-3 in 10 patients.50% of the patients older than 75 years were informed of their diagnosis, while the disclosure rate for those younger than 75 years was 90.5%. The reasons for non-disclosure were mental disturbance by dimentia in 2 patients and patient's request in one, while in 5 patients cancer was not disclosed because of their advanced age, advanced stage, family's preference, or the former doctor's policy.Surgery was performed in 10 patients, radiotherapy in 1, and chemotherapy in 1. Four patients did not undergo any therapy because of their highly advanced stage, poor general condition, or of their family's refusal. Seven of 10 patients who underwent surgery survived in good health and recovered to the level of preoperative ADL, although 1 patient died of neck metastasis, 1 of distant metastasis, and 1 was not followed up. 近年, 医療の進歩とともに高齢者口腔癌患者に対しても根治手術が行われるようになってきた。治療法を決定する上でインフォームドコンセントが重要であるが, わが国では従来高齢者に対する癌告知は避けられる傾向があった。今回, 高齢者口腔癌患者について, 癌告知を含めたインフォームドコンセン1・の現状を中心に検討した。対象患者は2000年より2002年に当科を受診した75歳以上の口腔癌患者ユ6例で, 臨床病期はstage III-IVの進展例が多かった。16例中14例で痴呆, 高任猛圧, 心疾患, 脳梗塞, 肺疾患, 腎疾患, リウマチなどの全身疾患を合併していた。performance status (PS) は0~1が6例, 2~3が10例であった。本人への癌告知率は50%であった。一方, 同時期の75歳未満の患者に対する告1知率は90.5%でった。非告知の理由は, 重度の痴呆のため認知障害があったものが2例, および本人が告知を希望しなかったものが1例あったが, 他の5例では年齢, 腫瘍の進展度, 予後の見通し, 家族の意向, 前医との継続性などを総合的に判断し告知を行わなかった。治療法としては手術が10例, 放射線治療, 化学療法がそれぞれ1例に行われたが, 4例では高度進展, 全身状態不良, 家族の拒否などにより治療は施行できなかった。手術を行った10例の予後は, 頸部非制御死, 遠隔転移死, 不明が各1例ずつみられたが, 他の7例は無病生存中で, 術前と同様のADLに回復した。
Radical operation has been more frequently applied to elderly patients with oral cancer, as a rezult of recent development in medical treatment In general, informed consent is important for patients to choose their treatment, but in Japan elderly patients with cancer have not usually been informed of their diagnosis. We studied elderly patients with oral cancer clinically, with special reference to the current trend of informed consent including cancer disclosure. The subjects of this study were 16 patients over 75 with oral cancer who were treated at our hospital between 2000 and 2002. Most of them had rather advanced cancer of stage III-IV. Fourteen of the 16 patients had some associated diseases, such as dimentia, hypertension, heart disease, cerebral infarction, lung disease, kidney disease, and rheumatism. Performance status (PS) was 0-1 in 6 patients, and 2-3 in 10 patients. 50% of the patients older than 75 years were informed of their diagnosis, while the disclosure rate for those younger than 75 years was 90.5%. The reasons for non-disclosure were mental disturbance by dimentia in 2 patients and patient's request in one, while in 5 patients cancer was not disclosed because of their advanced age, advanced stage, family's preference, or the former doctor's policy. Surgery was performed in 10 patients, radiotherapy in 1, and chemotherapy in 1. Four patients did not undergo any therapy because of their highly advanced stage, poor general condition, or of their family's refusal. Seven of 10 patients who underwent surgery survived in good health and recovered to the level of preoperative ADL, although 1 patient died of neck metastasis, 1 of distant metastasis, and 1 was not followed up.
Author Minamikawa, Tsutomu
Shibuya, Yasuyuki
Yokoo, Satoshi
Ishida, Yoshiki
Komori, Takahide
Ojima, Yasutaka
Fujioka, Manabu
Umeda, Masahiro
Komatsubara, Hideki
Author_FL 古森 孝英
石田 佳毅
横尾 聡
小松原 秀紀
藤岡 学
南川 勉
梅田 正博
尾島 泰公
渋谷 恭之
Author_FL_xml – sequence: 1
  fullname: 梅田 正博
– sequence: 2
  fullname: 小松原 秀紀
– sequence: 3
  fullname: 尾島 泰公
– sequence: 4
  fullname: 石田 佳毅
– sequence: 5
  fullname: 南川 勉
– sequence: 6
  fullname: 藤岡 学
– sequence: 7
  fullname: 渋谷 恭之
– sequence: 8
  fullname: 横尾 聡
– sequence: 9
  fullname: 古森 孝英
Author_xml – sequence: 1
  fullname: Komori, Takahide
  organization: Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Kobe University Graduate School of Medicine
– sequence: 1
  fullname: Fujioka, Manabu
  organization: Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Kobe University Graduate School of Medicine
– sequence: 1
  fullname: Yokoo, Satoshi
  organization: Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Kobe University Graduate School of Medicine
– sequence: 1
  fullname: Shibuya, Yasuyuki
  organization: Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Kobe University Graduate School of Medicine
– sequence: 1
  fullname: Umeda, Masahiro
  organization: Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Kobe University Graduate School of Medicine
– sequence: 1
  fullname: Ishida, Yoshiki
  organization: Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Kobe University Graduate School of Medicine
– sequence: 1
  fullname: Minamikawa, Tsutomu
  organization: Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Kobe University Graduate School of Medicine
– sequence: 1
  fullname: Komatsubara, Hideki
  organization: Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Kobe University Graduate School of Medicine
– sequence: 1
  fullname: Ojima, Yasutaka
  organization: Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Kobe University Graduate School of Medicine
BackLink https://cir.nii.ac.jp/crid/1390001204331221376$$DView record in CiNii
BookMark eNo9kL1vwjAUxK2KSqWUtbOHrkn9bCd-2YpS-iUkKpU9Mo4DRq6p7KCK_75BoC53w_vd6eluySjsgyXkHlgOwIvqcZc2UKHKAXOOV2QMiDJTgosRGbMKZCawLG_INCW3ZgXKSvJCjcnHjNbeBWe0p1_9oT3SfUdrHYyN9Nkl4_fpEC11gc59a6M_0k_dOxv6RH9dv6XLOATP_B257rRPdnrxCVm9zFf1W7ZYvr7Xs0W2Gz7INCiGiAxQYccsY2VbMVYYJZlSRigsi5ajrTTXrTTdupMgEYrOSKa1sYWYkIdzbXCuMe6kIIYKBpxJIYBzEKocsKcztku93tjmJ7pvHY-Njr0z3jaXvRrABk7C8f9ktjo2Nog_gOdkug
ContentType Journal Article
Copyright Japanese Society of Gerodontology
Copyright_xml – notice: Japanese Society of Gerodontology
DBID RYH
DOI 10.11259/jsg1987.18.28
DatabaseName CiNii Complete
DatabaseTitleList

DeliveryMethod fulltext_linktorsrc
DocumentTitleAlternate 高齢者口腔癌患者への癌告知に関する臨床的研究
DocumentTitle_FL 高齢者口腔癌患者への癌告知に関する臨床的研究
EISSN 1884-7323
EndPage 35
ExternalDocumentID 130004300806
article_jsg1987_18_1_18_28_article_char_en
GroupedDBID ABJNI
ACGFS
ALMA_UNASSIGNED_HOLDINGS
JSF
KQ8
RJT
RYH
ID FETCH-LOGICAL-j866-a17088801878f0e006d9005c74077c37865d28e9a2ad4cfbf414815fc40aace53
ISSN 0914-3866
IngestDate Fri Jun 27 00:17:27 EDT 2025
Wed Sep 03 06:23:46 EDT 2025
IsDoiOpenAccess true
IsOpenAccess true
IsPeerReviewed false
IsScholarly false
Issue 1
Language Japanese
LinkModel OpenURL
MergedId FETCHMERGED-LOGICAL-j866-a17088801878f0e006d9005c74077c37865d28e9a2ad4cfbf414815fc40aace53
OpenAccessLink https://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/jsg1987/18/1/18_28/_article/-char/en
PageCount 8
ParticipantIDs nii_cinii_1390001204331221376
jstage_primary_article_jsg1987_18_1_18_28_article_char_en
PublicationCentury 2000
PublicationDate 2003/06/30
PublicationDateYYYYMMDD 2003-06-30
PublicationDate_xml – month: 06
  year: 2003
  text: 2003/06/30
  day: 30
PublicationDecade 2000
PublicationTitle Ronen Shika Igaku
PublicationTitleAlternate Ronen Shika Igaku
PublicationTitle_FL 老年歯科医学
Japanese Journal of Gerodontology
JJGerodont
老年歯学
J J Gerodont
PublicationYear 2003
Publisher Japanese Society of Gerodontology
一般社団法人 日本老年歯科医学会
Publisher_xml – name: Japanese Society of Gerodontology
– name: 一般社団法人 日本老年歯科医学会
References 5) 黒川英雄, 武田忍, 三浦恵子, 中村貴司: 高齢者口腔扁平上皮癌の臨床的検討, 日口診誌, 13: 346-351, 2000.
9) 判例時報1522号: 104頁.
1) 相馬基逸, 松本光彦, 生木俊輔, 大木秀郎, 小野正道, 佐藤廣, 長谷川光晴, 堀稔, 田中博, 島本智恵, 高田耕司: 超高齢口腔癌患者に対する根治手術施行症例6例の検討, 日大歯学, 73: 535-540, 1999.
12) 渡辺亨: わが国の臨床試験の現状, 年報医事法学13: 34, 1988.
6) Elwyn TS, Fetters MD, Gorenflo W, Tsuda T. Cancer disclosure in Japan: historical comparisons, current practices. Soc Sci Med, 46: 1151-1163, 1998.
11) 判例時報1786号: 97頁.
7) Winton R. The Declaration of Lisbon: patients have right, too. Med J Aust, 1: 101, 1982.
8) 水澤亜紀子: 末期癌患者の家族への告知義務, 最高裁で初めて要件を提示, Nikkei Medica12003年1月号: 92-94, 2003.
2) 柳沢繁孝, 清水正嗣, 松島凛太郎, 小野敬一郎, 水城春美: 超高齢口腔癌患者の治療法改善に関する研究-当科における80歳以上の15症例を対象として-, 口腔腫瘍, 6: 86-94, 1994.
10) 判例時報1770号: 109頁.
3) 奥村隆司, 前田一, 松永亮: 高齢者頭頸部癌の検討, 頭頸部腫瘍, 15: 138-142, 1989.
4) 石川好美, 海野智, 川辺良一, 斎藤友克, 小林園生, 大村進, 小野繁, 藤田浄秀: 超高齢者の口腔癌治療に関する臨床的検討, 口腔腫瘍, 7: 312-318, 1995.
References_xml – reference: 11) 判例時報1786号: 97頁.
– reference: 7) Winton R. The Declaration of Lisbon: patients have right, too. Med J Aust, 1: 101, 1982.
– reference: 10) 判例時報1770号: 109頁.
– reference: 5) 黒川英雄, 武田忍, 三浦恵子, 中村貴司: 高齢者口腔扁平上皮癌の臨床的検討, 日口診誌, 13: 346-351, 2000.
– reference: 6) Elwyn TS, Fetters MD, Gorenflo W, Tsuda T. Cancer disclosure in Japan: historical comparisons, current practices. Soc Sci Med, 46: 1151-1163, 1998.
– reference: 12) 渡辺亨: わが国の臨床試験の現状, 年報医事法学13: 34, 1988.
– reference: 9) 判例時報1522号: 104頁.
– reference: 1) 相馬基逸, 松本光彦, 生木俊輔, 大木秀郎, 小野正道, 佐藤廣, 長谷川光晴, 堀稔, 田中博, 島本智恵, 高田耕司: 超高齢口腔癌患者に対する根治手術施行症例6例の検討, 日大歯学, 73: 535-540, 1999.
– reference: 8) 水澤亜紀子: 末期癌患者の家族への告知義務, 最高裁で初めて要件を提示, Nikkei Medica12003年1月号: 92-94, 2003.
– reference: 2) 柳沢繁孝, 清水正嗣, 松島凛太郎, 小野敬一郎, 水城春美: 超高齢口腔癌患者の治療法改善に関する研究-当科における80歳以上の15症例を対象として-, 口腔腫瘍, 6: 86-94, 1994.
– reference: 4) 石川好美, 海野智, 川辺良一, 斎藤友克, 小林園生, 大村進, 小野繁, 藤田浄秀: 超高齢者の口腔癌治療に関する臨床的検討, 口腔腫瘍, 7: 312-318, 1995.
– reference: 3) 奥村隆司, 前田一, 松永亮: 高齢者頭頸部癌の検討, 頭頸部腫瘍, 15: 138-142, 1989.
SSID ssib058494257
ssib004001984
ssj0000491487
Score 1.3746287
Snippet Radical operation has been more frequently applied to elderly patients with oral cancer, as a rezult of recent development in medical treatment In general,...
SourceID nii
jstage
SourceType Publisher
StartPage 28
SubjectTerms Disclosure of diagnosis
Elderly patient
Informed consent
Oral cancer
Patient's autonomy
インフォームドコンセント
口腔癌
患者の自己決定権
癌告知
高齢患者
Title A Clinical Study of Cancer Disclosure in Elderly Patients with Oral Cancer
URI https://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/jsg1987/18/1/18_28/_article/-char/en
https://cir.nii.ac.jp/crid/1390001204331221376
Volume 18
hasFullText 1
inHoldings 1
isFullTextHit
isPrint
ispartofPNX Ronen Shika Igaku, 2003/06/30, Vol.18(1), pp.28-35
link http://utb.summon.serialssolutions.com/2.0.0/link/0/eLvHCXMwpV3Nb9MwFLe6ceGChgAxtiEfuE0p-arjHKtqYwwBAoo0TpHjOKubkaC1OZR_hX-W92I7TTUOAy5WlTqR7ffL-4rfz4S8Cgt4m9Pc91QcSC_mqfTSXELUKiYsZwKCrghrh99_YBdf48urydVo9Guwa6ld52P58491Jf8iVbgGcsUq2b-QbP9QuAC_Qb7QgoShvZeMp6czV9j4xZFDz1CMt8iqKW8aTP9hRuMMz-K-2SAhv96WtH3E4nzTf-ijfm5qBS_9Qlfi9O21qNpeKTffG1OYPheVWOiiB8V5u9RNJUzxTy3ydqtMqqYxmed1s1roPqGz0Hm76W74Jlbtpq30Tv4hcpvlnG0Am45nZfa7TGGmbxQof6Rf6D8M2JRjEHsRZ5b62ihczmMviUzN8V2N3CPPqlc-MNSG5uSuCYCADm3A6hrzKeOAj91dO7TaVmiZ7ZcFPAuwCXnm_sK6N4DZHnkQJkm3B-DdJz5UfnBjr8zAkUtR__UJPgi9INTsyvXdvC1pKI7w9c74wP1ZQjCALA97tdYDD2d-QB7Z0IROzbgek9FSPCGXU-owRjuM0aakBjN0izGqa2oxRh3GKGKMIsZs_6dkfn42n1149vwNbwmD9USQgAnieGojL30F6rlIQWfLJPaTREYJZ5Mi5CoVoShiWeZlHCDzTyljXwipJtEzsl8DYp8TCn69YrCETOEi5VKAoRHgyDNVlDLx2SFJzfyzH4ZjJbu_eA7JCSxZJjW2EM90uVWk5QvCMADz-eI_nn1EHm4hf0z217etOgEndJ2_7MDwG_27hrk
linkProvider Colorado Alliance of Research Libraries
openUrl ctx_ver=Z39.88-2004&ctx_enc=info%3Aofi%2Fenc%3AUTF-8&rfr_id=info%3Asid%2Fsummon.serialssolutions.com&rft_val_fmt=info%3Aofi%2Ffmt%3Akev%3Amtx%3Ajournal&rft.genre=article&rft.atitle=A+Clinical+Study+of+Cancer+Disclosure+in+Elderly+Patients+with+Oral+Cancer&rft.jtitle=Ronen+Shika+Igaku&rft.au=Komori%2C+Takahide&rft.au=Fujioka%2C+Manabu&rft.au=Yokoo%2C+Satoshi&rft.au=Shibuya%2C+Yasuyuki&rft.date=2003-06-30&rft.pub=Japanese+Society+of+Gerodontology&rft.issn=0914-3866&rft.eissn=1884-7323&rft.volume=18&rft.issue=1&rft.spage=28&rft.epage=35&rft_id=info:doi/10.11259%2Fjsg1987.18.28&rft.externalDocID=article_jsg1987_18_1_18_28_article_char_en
thumbnail_l http://covers-cdn.summon.serialssolutions.com/index.aspx?isbn=/lc.gif&issn=0914-3866&client=summon
thumbnail_m http://covers-cdn.summon.serialssolutions.com/index.aspx?isbn=/mc.gif&issn=0914-3866&client=summon
thumbnail_s http://covers-cdn.summon.serialssolutions.com/index.aspx?isbn=/sc.gif&issn=0914-3866&client=summon