Suomen sijamuotojen nimitykset: kuinka käsiteanalyysi ja tuotekehittely 1800-luvun kieliopeissa saataisiin hyödyttämään S2- ja äidinkielen opetusta?
This study discusses the naming system for the Finnish nominal cases as a terminological product and the research material is a collection of 17th–19th century grammars of the Finnish language. According to the findings, it can safely be concluded that most of our terms for the Finnish nominal cases...
Saved in:
Published in | Lähivertailuja Vol. 28; no. 28; pp. 143 - 177 |
---|---|
Main Author | |
Format | Journal Article |
Language | Finnish English |
Published |
Eesti Rakenduslingvistika Ühing (ERÜ)
01.10.2018
Estonian Association for Applied Linguistics (EAAL) Eesti Rakenduslingvistika Ühing = Estonian Association for Applied Linguistics |
Subjects | |
Online Access | Get full text |
Cover
Loading…
Abstract | This study discusses the naming system for the Finnish nominal cases as a terminological product and the research material is a collection of 17th–19th century grammars of the Finnish language. According to the findings, it can safely be concluded that most of our terms for the Finnish nominal cases originate from the 19th century. Te term systems used to describe the Finnish nominal cases changed many times before the current terminology was accepted as official. Te development process that leads to the terminology we have now has been long but cannot be called gradual. On the contrary, most changes in the terminological system were abrupt and may be considered conscious choices of individual scholars. Special attention in this study is given to the term system used to denote the six Finnish local cases: inessive, elative, illative, adessive, ablative and allative. This system is currently applied in most reference grammars and standard works for studying L1 and L2 Finnish and it can rightfully be attributed to Gustav Renvall (1840). Not only was this system used for the first time by Renvall, but in his grammar “Finsk Språklära Enligt den rena VestFinska” Renvall also takes credit for the new terms and gives a lengthy account of their structure and meaning. Renvall also argues why his terms should be used instead of those suggested by i.e. Vhael (1733) and von Becker (1824). From a conceptual analytical point of view, Renvall’s terms pass scrutiny on many levels. Te terms are by no means incorrect or misleading. Each of them gives valid information about the meaning and use of the respective case. They also are innovative and original: only “ablative” has been used in previous grammars. Te other five terms are all new and tailor-made in order to describe the core meanings of the Finnish local cases. In the language learning context, however, Renvall’s terms appear to be problematic. They are based on Latin prepositional verbs, which may have been a helpful feature during Renvall’s lifetime but has become a disadvantage in modern-day classroom usage. Especially in L1 and L2 Finnish on the elementary level, there is a need for alternative or parallel terminology that is not only accurate but also user-friendly. A good starting point for further development might be to utilize the term system of Reinhold von Becker which is not without merits, although it was set aside shortly after Renvall’s grammar appeared. Practical experience of all who teach Finnish on any educational level will probably be of great value as well. |
---|---|
AbstractList | Artikkeli on oppihistoriallinen katsaus suomen sijamuotojen nimitysten kehityksestä ja erityisesti paikallissijojen nimitysjärjestelmän muotoutumisesta nykyiseen asuunsa. Tutkimusaineistona on käytetty sijamuotojärjestelmän kuvauksia 1800-luvun kieliopeissa, erityisesti Gustaf Renvallin teoksessa “Finsk Språklära, Enligt den rena Vest-Finska, i Bokspråk vanliga Dialecten”. Suomen paikallissijojen nykyistä nimitysjärjestelmää voidaan suurelta osin pitää Renvallin kehittämänä terminologisena tuotteena, jonka perusteita ja kehittelyprosessia hän myös teoksessaan seikkaperäisesti esittelee. Vaikka Renvallin luomat nimitykset (inessiv,elativ, illativ, adessiv, ablativ, allativ) ovat sisällöllisesti oikeat ja perustuvat hyvään käsiteanalyysiin, ne ovat kuitenkin osoittautuneet ongelmallisiksi. Erityisesti perusasteen äidinkielenopetuksessa ja S2-opetuksessa nämä latinaan pohjautuvat termit ovat työläitä muistaa ja jäävät helposti vieraiksi käyttäjilleen. Lisäksi Renvallin termistö on syrjäyttänyt tieltään aikaisempia kuvausmalleja, joissa olisi ollut ainesta jatkokehittelyyn. Vaikka Renvallin termijärjestelmästä ei ole syytä luopua, vaihtoehtoja sille tarvittaisiin. Hyvän lähtökohdan vaihtoehtoisille tai rinnakkaisille nimityksille voisivat tarjota Reinhold von Beckerin käyttämät termit, jotka ovat aiheettomasti jääneet unohduksiin. Myös August Ahlqvistin deskriptiivisiä nimityksiä (sisäinen/ulkoinen olosija, erosijaja tulosija) kannattaisi hyödyntää aktiivisemmin opetuksessa. Lisää aineksia vaihtoehtoisille termeille tarjoaa myös Kalevi Wiikin tutkimus suomen sijamuotojen nimityksistä. *** "On the naming system of the Finnish nominal cases: Concept analysis and product development in the 19th century Finnish grammars" This study discusses the naming system for the Finnish nominal cases as a terminological product and the research material is a collection of 17th–19th century grammars of the Finnish language. According to the findings, it can safely be concluded that most of our terms for the Finnish nominal cases originate from the 19th century. The term systems used to describe the Finnish nominal cases changed many times before the current terminology was accepted as official. The development process that leads to the terminology we have now has been long but cannot be called gradual. On the contrary, most changes in the terminological system were abrupt and may be considered conscious choices of individual scholars. Special attention in this study is given to the term system used to denote the six Finnish local cases: inessive, elative, illative, adessive, ablative and allative. This system is currently applied in most reference grammars and standard works for studying L1 and L2 Finnish and it can rightfully be attributed to Gustav Renvall (1840). Not only was this system used for the first time by Renvall, but in his grammar “Finsk Språklära Enligt den rena Vest-Finska” Renvall also takes credit for the new terms and gives a lengthy account of their structure and meaning. Renvall also argues why his terms should be used instead of those suggested by i.e. Vhael (1733) and von Becker (1824). This study discusses the naming system for the Finnish nominal cases as a terminological product and the research material is a collection of 17th–19th century grammars of the Finnish language. According to the findings, it can safely be concluded that most of our terms for the Finnish nominal cases originate from the 19th century. Te term systems used to describe the Finnish nominal cases changed many times before the current terminology was accepted as official. Te development process that leads to the terminology we have now has been long but cannot be called gradual. On the contrary, most changes in the terminological system were abrupt and may be considered conscious choices of individual scholars. Special attention in this study is given to the term system used to denote the six Finnish local cases: inessive, elative, illative, adessive, ablative and allative. This system is currently applied in most reference grammars and standard works for studying L1 and L2 Finnish and it can rightfully be attributed to Gustav Renvall (1840). Not only was this system used for the first time by Renvall, but in his grammar “Finsk Språklära Enligt den rena VestFinska” Renvall also takes credit for the new terms and gives a lengthy account of their structure and meaning. Renvall also argues why his terms should be used instead of those suggested by i.e. Vhael (1733) and von Becker (1824). From a conceptual analytical point of view, Renvall’s terms pass scrutiny on many levels. Te terms are by no means incorrect or misleading. Each of them gives valid information about the meaning and use of the respective case. They also are innovative and original: only “ablative” has been used in previous grammars. Te other five terms are all new and tailor-made in order to describe the core meanings of the Finnish local cases. In the language learning context, however, Renvall’s terms appear to be problematic. They are based on Latin prepositional verbs, which may have been a helpful feature during Renvall’s lifetime but has become a disadvantage in modern-day classroom usage. Especially in L1 and L2 Finnish on the elementary level, there is a need for alternative or parallel terminology that is not only accurate but also user-friendly. A good starting point for further development might be to utilize the term system of Reinhold von Becker which is not without merits, although it was set aside shortly after Renvall’s grammar appeared. Practical experience of all who teach Finnish on any educational level will probably be of great value as well. |
Author | Kok, Maria |
Author_xml | – sequence: 1 fullname: Kok, Maria |
BookMark | eNotkF2KFTEQhYOM4HUc3IAP2UCP-b1J-yIyODpwwYcZfG3qdqqd9E8ydNJCb8XnXoMb6I0ZHaGgqEOd7xT1mlyEGJCQt5xday7s-9N3Ya-ZekEOQghbSavVBTlwI49VLWr2ilyl5M9MKaM5r-WB_Lpf4oSBJt_DtMQc-zIEP_m8DgnzBzosPgxAh31LPiMEGNc1edoDzWUdB3z0OeO4Um4Zq8bl5xLo4HH08Ql9SkATQAafvA_0cd1_uzXnfZv2bd8CvRfVX9K-eVdSiquEF19eUoaPb8jLDsaEV__7JXm4_fxw87U6fftyd_PpVLXWqEqhdch5Ke5qAdKdhWFHXhvdcbRdq1tnuFCtNArPHF3b1dqJrtNag64Vykty94x1EfrmafYTzGsTwTf_hDj_aGDOvh2xkcKgccq6Wp-VMBo65MxoxsEdywGqsN49s1rEODZ9XObysNRYJo1k8g83o4ij |
ContentType | Journal Article |
DBID | AE2 BIXPP REL DOA |
DOI | 10.5128/LV28.04 |
DatabaseName | Central and Eastern European Online Library (C.E.E.O.L.) (DFG Nationallizenzen) CEEOL: Open Access Central and Eastern European Online Library - CEEOL Journals Directory of Open Access Journals - May need to register for free articles |
DatabaseTitleList | |
Database_xml | – sequence: 1 dbid: DOA name: DOAJ Directory of Open Access Journals url: https://www.doaj.org/ sourceTypes: Open Website |
DeliveryMethod | fulltext_linktorsrc |
Discipline | Languages & Literatures |
DocumentTitleAlternate | On the naming system of the Finnish nominal cases: Concept analysis and product development in the 19th century Finnish grammars |
EISSN | 2228-3854 |
EndPage | 177 |
ExternalDocumentID | oai_doaj_org_article_327e7d48d95b4275afe107501ad6e114 803730 |
GroupedDBID | AE2 ALMA_UNASSIGNED_HOLDINGS BIXPP M~E REL ECE EN8 EOJEC GROUPED_DOAJ IN- OBODZ OK1 RNS |
ID | FETCH-LOGICAL-c874-4e8de11e111d92a3db27061975f1e8fc5cd7124c374eb1edcf95d2ff555a594e3 |
IEDL.DBID | DOA |
ISSN | 1736-9290 |
IngestDate | Thu Jul 04 21:09:35 EDT 2024 Thu Sep 26 15:15:36 EDT 2024 |
IsDoiOpenAccess | true |
IsOpenAccess | true |
IsPeerReviewed | true |
IsScholarly | true |
Issue | 28 |
Keywords | history of grammar tradition Finnish local cases grammatical terminology L2 Finnish learning L1 Finnish learning case system of Finnish |
Language | Finnish English |
LinkModel | DirectLink |
MergedId | FETCHMERGED-LOGICAL-c874-4e8de11e111d92a3db27061975f1e8fc5cd7124c374eb1edcf95d2ff555a594e3 |
OpenAccessLink | https://doaj.org/article/327e7d48d95b4275afe107501ad6e114 |
PageCount | 35 |
ParticipantIDs | doaj_primary_oai_doaj_org_article_327e7d48d95b4275afe107501ad6e114 ceeol_journals_803730 |
PublicationCentury | 2000 |
PublicationDate | 2018-10-01 |
PublicationDateYYYYMMDD | 2018-10-01 |
PublicationDate_xml | – month: 10 year: 2018 text: 2018-10-01 day: 01 |
PublicationDecade | 2010 |
PublicationTitle | Lähivertailuja |
PublicationTitleAlternate | Close Comparisons |
PublicationYear | 2018 |
Publisher | Eesti Rakenduslingvistika Ühing (ERÜ) Estonian Association for Applied Linguistics (EAAL) Eesti Rakenduslingvistika Ühing = Estonian Association for Applied Linguistics |
Publisher_xml | – name: Estonian Association for Applied Linguistics (EAAL) – name: Eesti Rakenduslingvistika Ühing (ERÜ) – name: Eesti Rakenduslingvistika Ühing = Estonian Association for Applied Linguistics |
SSID | ssib044751193 ssib038074924 ssib007484590 ssib008351981 ssib012295270 ssj0000516704 |
Score | 2.101128 |
Snippet | This study discusses the naming system for the Finnish nominal cases as a terminological product and the research material is a collection of 17th–19th century... Artikkeli on oppihistoriallinen katsaus suomen sijamuotojen nimitysten kehityksestä ja erityisesti paikallissijojen nimitysjärjestelmän muotoutumisesta... |
SourceID | doaj ceeol |
SourceType | Open Website Publisher |
StartPage | 143 |
SubjectTerms | 17th Century 18th Century 19th Century case system of Finnish Finnish local cases Finno-Ugrian studies grammatical terminology historialliset kieliopit Historical Linguistics kielioppitermistö L1 Finnish learning L2 Finnish learning Morphology S2-opetus sijojen nimitykset sisäpaikallissijat suomi äidinkielenä -opetus ulkopaikallissijat |
Title | Suomen sijamuotojen nimitykset: kuinka käsiteanalyysi ja tuotekehittely 1800-luvun kieliopeissa saataisiin hyödyttämään S2- ja äidinkielen opetusta? |
URI | https://www.ceeol.com//search/article-detail?id=803730 https://doaj.org/article/327e7d48d95b4275afe107501ad6e114 |
Volume | 28 |
hasFullText | 1 |
inHoldings | 1 |
isFullTextHit | |
isPrint | |
link | http://utb.summon.serialssolutions.com/2.0.0/link/0/eLvHCXMwrZ3NbtQwEMctVC5cEB8Fypd8QNxM14kdO70gQK0qtOXSgnqLnNhWs9kmFXEq7YUH4Zxn4AXyYswkEbucuCBFkRLFkTKe5D-2M78h5E0a-Vx4m7DYG81AjzkziXUMtGjhhLZ-mro4-5KcfhWfL-XlTqkv_CdswgNPhjuMI-WUhVapzEWkpPGOo8xxYxPH-UQC5XJnMIWehIRMubP-o7EO3TbDkmMR62jrqUhdF-mWW44UPM5nz50p4YkaaxFyFScMYorFlIELeqkPl98i_Q5Lvd0FyWnWf-H_R506eUDuzwEm_TA92ENyx9WPyNPlPC3Z0rd0-Yek3D4mP887ZDDQtlyZ664JzQoOasx62lStC0e06mC0amg19LjObJBhAj1LV4YGuNxV7qoMwa03lENQyNbdbVfTqnTrsrlx0KmGtsYEU7ZlWdOrzfDLbkIY-uuhH_qankcM7zT0pcUaDiiBFNoFzOp6v08uTo4vPp2yuV4DK7QSTDhtoUdg4zaNTGxzsDCMz5T03GlfyMIqiCaKWAkQCGcLn0obeS-lNDIVLn5C9uqmds8IzYUwIkVWowf1dLHRMkktDA0heo0jXhyQ_dHS2fzCtZlexPCtOiAf0fLZzUTqyJCdPZ4Aj8pmj8r-5VHP_8dNXpB7EFpN5Fz-kuyF7517BeFLyF-Pngr7sx_HvwGac-sb |
link.rule.ids | 315,786,790,870,2115,27957,27958 |
linkProvider | Directory of Open Access Journals |
openUrl | ctx_ver=Z39.88-2004&ctx_enc=info%3Aofi%2Fenc%3AUTF-8&rfr_id=info%3Asid%2Fsummon.serialssolutions.com&rft_val_fmt=info%3Aofi%2Ffmt%3Akev%3Amtx%3Ajournal&rft.genre=article&rft.atitle=Suomen+sijamuotojen+nimitykset%3A+kuinka+k%C3%A4siteanalyysi+ja+tuotekehittely+1800-luvun+kieliopeissa+saataisiin+hy%C3%B6dytt%C3%A4m%C3%A4%C3%A4n+S2-+ja+%C3%A4idinkielen+opetusta%3F&rft.jtitle=L%C3%A4hiv%C5%91rdlusi.+L%C3%A4hivertailuja&rft.au=Kok%2C+Maria&rft.date=2018-10-01&rft.pub=Eesti+Rakenduslingvistika+%C3%9Ching+%28ER%C3%9C%29&rft.issn=1736-9290&rft.issue=28&rft.spage=143&rft.epage=177&rft_id=info:doi/10.5128%2FLV28.04&rft.externalDocID=803730 |
thumbnail_s | http://utb.summon.serialssolutions.com/2.0.0/image/custom?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ceeol.com%2F%2Fapi%2Fimage%2Fgetissuecoverimage%3Fid%3Dpicture_2018_50154.png |