There’s nothing inherent about scale: political ecology, the local trap, and the politics of development in the Brazilian Amazon

• Published in: Geoforum Vol. 36; no. 5; pp. 607 - 624
• Main Authors: Christopher Brown, J., Purcell, Mark
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Oxford Elsevier Ltd 01.09.2005; New York, NY Pergamon Press
• Subjects: Amazon; Amazonian Basin; America; Bgi / Prodig; Brazil; Brazil. Amazonian Basin; Case studies; Environmental change; Geography; Methodology; Political ecology; Political economy; Scale; Scale analysis; Brazil; Amazon Basin; South America, Amazon R; Brazil; Scale; Political economy; Political ecology; Policy; Sovereignty; Development; Man-environment relations; Research; Spatial embeddedness
• ISSN: 0016-7185; 1872-9398
• DOI: 10.1016/j.geoforum.2004.09.001

This paper argues that research in political ecology would benefit from more explicit and careful attention to the question of scale and scalar politics. Although political ecologists have extensively considered scale as a methodological question, they have yet to develop an explicit theoretical approach to scale as an object of inquiry. We highlight one principal drawback to this underdeveloped approach to scale: what we call “the local trap” in which political ecologists assume that organization, policies, and action at the local scale are inherently more likely to have desired social and ecological effects than activities organized at other scales. Over the past 10 years or so, an increasingly sophisticated literature on scale has been developing among scholars in geography working in the political economy tradition. This literature has argued that scale is socially produced rather than ontologically given. Therefore, there is nothing inherent about any scale, and so the local scale cannot be intrinsically more desirable than other scales. We suggest that a greater engagement with this scale literature offers political ecology a theoretical way out of the local trap. As a first approximation of the kind of scalar analysis we advocate, we present a case study that examines the scalar politics that have shaped environmental change in the Brazilian Amazon.