Anterior inferior plating versus superior plating for clavicle fracture: a meta-analysis

• Published in: BMC musculoskeletal disorders Vol. 18; no. 1; pp. 159 - 9
• Main Authors: Ai, Jie, Kan, Shun-Li, Li, Hai-Liang, Xu, Hong, Liu, Yang, Ning, Guang-Zhi, Feng, Shi-Qing
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: England BioMed Central 18.04.2017; BMC
• Subjects: Anterior inferior plating; Bias; Biomechanics; Bone Plates; Clavicle; Clavicle - injuries; Clavicle fracture; Clinical trials; Confidence Intervals; Fracture Fixation, Internal - adverse effects; Fracture Fixation, Internal - instrumentation; Fracture Fixation, Internal - methods; Fracture Healing; Fractures, Bone - surgery; Handbooks; Humans; Literature reviews; Meta-analysis; Nonunion; Observational Studies as Topic; Quality; Randomized Controlled Trials as Topic; Studies; Superior plating; Surgical Wound Infection - epidemiology; Time Factors; Trauma; Superior plating; Anterior inferior plating; Clavicle fracture; Meta-analysis
• DOI: 10.1186/s12891-017-1517-1
• ISSN: 1471-2474

The position of plate fixation for clavicle fracture remains controversial. Our objective was to perform a comprehensive review of the literature and quantify the surgical parameters and clinical indexes between the anterior inferior plating and superior plating for clavicle fracture. PubMed, EMBASE, and the Cochrane Library were searched for randomized and non-randomized studies that compared the anterior inferior plating with the superior plating for clavicle fracture. The relative risk or standardized mean difference with 95% confidence interval was calculated using either a fixed- or random-effects model. Four randomized controlled trials and eight observational studies were identified to compare the surgical parameters and clinical indexes. For the surgical parameters, the anterior inferior plating group was better than the superior plating group in operation time and blood loss (P < 0.05). Furthermore, in terms of clinical indexes, the anterior inferior plating was superior to the superior plating in reducing the union time, and the two kinds of plate fixation methods were comparable in constant score, and the rate of infection, nonunion, and complications (P > 0.05). Based on the current evidence, the anterior inferior plating may reduce the blood loss, the operation and union time, but no differences were observed in constant score, and the rate of infection, nonunion, and complications between the two groups. Given that some of the studies have low quality, more randomized controlled trails with high quality should be conduct to further verify the findings.